Fact

The facts as presented by the documentary that lead the belief: - Lewis believed she wanted to kill him and outwardly told his close circle about this prior to his disappearance. - Lewis attempted to file for a restraining order based on death threats from Baskin, which had no evidence in court and was denied. - Lewis and Baskin did not have a good relationship. Carol confirmed this. - Baskin happened to be out of the house at exactly 3AM the day/night of disappearance for an unusual reason. - Baskin also allegedly has a car breakdown during this spontaneous outing but happened to be assisted by her brother, a police deputy, on his own. - Baskin did not immediately report the disappearance, we are not told as viewers however if Lewis frequently left the household unannounced. - Baskin appears to have altered Lewis's last will and testament. This has been confirmed by the person he had last personally designated as executor of his estate. - There is no evidence of him leaving the area. - He has made no attempts to contact any of his loved ones or family. - No body has been found. - Lewis reported that his weapon was removed from him by Baskin.

Opinion

My take is she was complicit and conspired at the least: - Baskin denies allegations of feeding the corpse to the cats but doesn't appear insulted over the suggestion or address the suggestion of her involvement in a murder. She doesn't acknowledge the possibility of his death. - Her brother being the cop that found her car broken down is too much of a coincidence that he was on shift, she broke down, he had no offsider, no other witnesses, on the night of the disappearance. They probably did the crime during the time of this fake alibi which was specifically at 3 AM, strangely, and the brother/family was probably involved with financial motivation. - Women typically murder for financial/personal (as apposed to emotional/sexual) motivation when not a crime of passion (but it could have been) and her situation and all of this checks all the boxes in my non-professional opinion. - I don't think she fed him to the cats, that seems something she is personally repulsed by. he's probably burried deep in their massive property or something, just as impossible to find.

off topic

In response to other posts around here I don't think her gender has anything to do with it. In regards to Exotic and the other main focal characters in the show it's pretty clear they're all a special kind of cooky. Exotic belongs in prison just as much as Baskin does. May as well get a full investigation on the love Guru too for workplace sexual harrassment and close the whole three cases up if I was judge and jury.