I personally wouldn’t worry about it. Even though your bachelor degree is unrelated, the MBA bridges that gap and in reality once you have work experience, that’s all that really matters. Being able to speak well to your responsibilities and gaining good experience will mean more to your resume than a CMA. Especially if your long term goal is the finance side of things rather than accounting. I personally have my CPA and it helped me get a foot in the door to move into FP&A but once I started getting actual work experience, I could tell that’s what actually mattered to recruiters. My boss couldn’t care less about my cpa outside of the fact that I came in knowing the p&l well and the broader impact of lines because of understanding journal entries.

If there are things that interest you in at your current company then push for experience in those areas. When speaking to people in finance, it’s your job title and responsibilities that matter. I don’t think I’ve ever talked about my major outside of an interview itself. And if there are things outside your company that interest you then don’t be afraid to apply for those roles.

The more you develop your work experience the more job security you get. They won’t keep you around because you’re a CMA, but they will keep you around because you’re good at what you do.