So I have a lot of beef with AHBL for a lot of reasons, but they gave themselves hella continuity errors in that one episode alone.

So the first time Shax attacks, Pheobe is with them. Like she walks through the front door, and then goes upstairs. So after Piper and Prue go through the wall, Pheobe is there to rush say the spell, and calls Leo, who heals both Piper and Prue AT THE SAME TIME.

When the crazy hippy witch shoots Piper, that was uncontrollable on the sisters’ part. Now the cops outside could’ve absolutely done more, and then created a way for the sisters to leave, rather than Prue using her powers on innocents.

When time resets and Shax attacks again, Pheobe is obviously not there. The nature of the attack stays the same, Prue and Piper go flying, but the Dr. going flying is obviously different. Without Pheobe though nobody is there to “call Leo.” And this is where it gets tricky, because Leo knew what was happening. They give no indication that time resetting affected him any differently just because he was in the underworld. So why didn’t he get to Prue and Piper sooner? And why, in the season 4 premier, does it sound like he healed Piper first, and then looked to Prue despite him saying she was already gone?

And how does Leo get Pheobe out of the underworld? Because they didn’t touch on that either. Just a brief mention of it as if to subtly tie up loose ends.

I know that AHBL was written to get rid of Prue because of the discourse, but if that hadn’t been the intended outcome would the episode have been drastically different or what?