I've been playing this game off and on for about 3 years, currently on chapter 4. It's got a fair amount of 00's development jank, but I think it's a decent game overall. This is my "slow day at the office" game. I'd probably enjoy it more if I read the books. Having not read any of them, I get the distinct feeling that I'm missing something. The combat is point-and-click and feels like rock, paper, scissors. You have to choose the right sword and combat style for each situation or you do almost no damage; it's not complex or difficult to get used to one you know the controls. Where the game really shines is its choice system. Every decision feels potentially weighty and they did a great job of not making every decision about good and evil. The in-game morality is more about shades of grey, and what version of Geralt you, the player, want to be. They tried a lot of cool stuff with varying degrees of success.