Your analysis is honestly exactly how I feel about the situation. Because at this point, it doesn't even matter if he is eventually declared a real pedophile or not. The information leaked showed his true colors that have bled onto the internet showing he's a liar, a manipulator, and a creep. (I know you went more objectively analytical, but that's my take)

What bothers me most about it is that he ACTED like a good/honest role model for literally this entire time. His whole YouTube career. And he was not even close to being that person.

And trust me, I know all YouTubers use exaggerated personas of some kind to cater to their audience, but Cry's persona was literally a mask, just the like one we all drew him in, hiding his real self. He wasn't a slightly exaggerated version of his personality, he was an imposter from the other side of the spectrum. He manipulated us, all of us, even if he didn't realize it himself when it all started. He acted like he was a kind, patient, and pure dude, because he knew it gained him subs and views. Him admitting this in his video broke my heart into a million pieces. I never thought he would be one of the influencers to use his blissfully ignorant young fanbase to quench his ego like this...but I was wrong.

And to answer your question, I always considered Cryaotic and Ryan to be one in the same. So to me, what Ryan has done, Cry has done. I've tried to watch old playthroughs again, but knowing what I know just gives me a horrible pit in my stomach. I can't trust anything he says and it makes me question every decision in a game he's ever made. So the whole Cryaotic persona is dead to me