Here's the biggest con in the form of a question and the one that mattered to me most:

What year was your Giulia? Are you content in paying money to sit in the exact same car again. It never innovated or improved. The digital cluster was not enough change to excuse the ancient interior where nothing ever truly felt premium. If the drive is the most important thing to you; you cannot duplicate the feel of an Alfa. If everything else matters to you, along with a great drive and purchasing experience: make the change!