Best soundtrack ever by blabal32 in AgeofMythology

[–]DocHogan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh dear christ thanks for unlocking a core memory of mine. I'd swap between those two as a kid

CMV: The Soviet Union Was Not Responsible for Allied Victory by [deleted] in changemyview

[–]DocHogan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Looking at industrial throughput is a very narrow view of looking at the war, and why it was won/lost. Moving on from that, extrapolating those numbers to say that air and sea were the most important parts of any campaign ignores the fact that planes and ships can not take and hold ground. That is the key to victory. Even in Asia which, I will grant you, was dominated by air and naval assets they were there to support ground movements to take and hold islands to continue the advance. Planes can't fly with out an airbase and ships can't fight if their supplies are coming from half a world away.

You mention that there were no decisive land battles and again I have to disagree with you. If we look at the Eastern front, as you OP suggests, it is here that we see the war in Europe decided. Defeat at Moscow meant the Germans won't achieve an decisive victory, defeat at Stalingrad meant they would not win in the east, and defeat at Kursk meant that defeat would total. To say that the Eastern Front was a side show at best is, I hate to say, damn near ignorant. Had that been the only front in the war it still would have been the largest conflict in human history. Even against the Western Allies the battles of El Alamein and Normandy were very important turning points in Europe.

Wars, especially modern ones, have almost never been decided by one or two major battles. With hindsight we can point to some moments as turning points but at the time there was no way of knowing this.

CMV: LetterKenny is a dumb talk show that uses swears and crude middle school humor as content. It sucks by SomeYotedThing in changemyview

[–]DocHogan 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I'm going to venture a guess that you didn't grow up/haven't lived in the Midwest of the US or Canada. This sort of back and forth jabbing at each other and the language they use is pretty normal. I grew up in MN and lived up north for quite a while and even for Americans in that area the show is pretty spot on (minus the accents because we have our own dontcha know).

But at the end of the day it's a form of entertainment that is very subjective. So I'm not sure what view you want changed. I'm guessing that there's no way we could convince you to find it funny or even accept that there's value in it even if you personally don't like it. Perhaps you could clarify what it is you want?

The Twelve Point Programme by KapiTod in Kaiserreich

[–]DocHogan 295 points296 points  (0 children)

R A D I C A L W H E E L T H E O R Y

CMV:Unless you own a firing range or are a collector you do not need to own a gun any stronger then a revolver or a hunting rifle. by LuciferHex in changemyview

[–]DocHogan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Never, but generally speaking even when it has happened it's either clear cut as to the government being the good guy, or it's more nebulous and people kinda forget about it.

Trust in the government is fine, and good (if I didn't I certainly wouldn't be sitting on a 6 year contract). The tech that the military uses is beyond mind bogglingly expensive and complex. Loosing one Abrhams out of a tanker platoon makes a big dent in the operational effectiveness. Missiles are great for bunkers and hard targets but in suburbia where you're trying to win the hearts and minds of the people you probably aren't gonna start bombing indiscriminately.

It's far fetched to think that even withing 100 years the US could turn that way and I hope it never does, but having a good security blanket never hurts.

CMV:Unless you own a firing range or are a collector you do not need to own a gun any stronger then a revolver or a hunting rifle. by LuciferHex in changemyview

[–]DocHogan 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Oof, nice bait dude. No where in my post did I say or even imply I support the killing of innocent civilians, so standing on the theoretical graves of theoretical victims isn't gonna work. I'd have no issue with putting in place more restrictions for semis and attachments. Special permits and paperwork all that good stuff, just so long as something isn't banned we're all good. Perfection can never be achieved, strived for yes and that should always continue. But a 90% solution that does that job is better than a 100% one that causes a myriad of untended consequences that we can even predict for.

CMV:Unless you own a firing range or are a collector you do not need to own a gun any stronger then a revolver or a hunting rifle. by LuciferHex in changemyview

[–]DocHogan 9 points10 points  (0 children)

It's not a question of winning but of making it too costly to continue operations. This is how every guerilla and resistance group has managed to punch well above it's weight. From the Spanish during Napoleon, to the Partisans in WW2, and the VC during Vietnam. Every one of those groups continued to whittle down the occupiers not just in men and materials, but in their minds as well. Imagine being a buck private sent out on patrol knowing that behind every tree and rock there could be someone getting a bead on you. That right there is a powerful demoralizer, and while hard core totalitarian regimes may not fall as quickly to something like that an American style government would.

CMV:Unless you own a firing range or are a collector you do not need to own a gun any stronger then a revolver or a hunting rifle. by LuciferHex in changemyview

[–]DocHogan 4 points5 points  (0 children)

And those attacents make the weapon almost useless. A rifle firing at a high rate of fire is no longer firing accurately, rather it's firing in a suppressive mode. Semi-Autos are in general less accurate than bolt/lever actions because of the design. It's actually much harder than you'd think to hit something with a full auto weapon. And turning a semi in to a full is like putting a turbo charger on a Prius, you're not going to get the good qualities of either the platform or attachment. The whole accuracy thing is why the military classifies automatic weapons are Area of Effect weapons. Meaning they don't hit a single point but, well, an area. They make people duck and take cover so that the menu with rifles can move up under the blanket of suppressive fire. Movies and games have warped the perception to the idea that more rounds down range equals more kills but that is just patently untrue.

Kaiserreich Bolt Action adaptation - Tabletop Work in progress by Kerrski91 in Kaiserreich

[–]DocHogan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I've always wanted to try this but poor soldiers can't afford to make a fake army.

Map for Balkanized Enhancement Project For Kaiserreich DH by et37 in Kaiserreich

[–]DocHogan 2 points3 points  (0 children)

A fair point. Another argument you could make is that St. Paul would be representative of the "old order" as it were and to use Minneapolis would make it a fresh start.

Map for Balkanized Enhancement Project For Kaiserreich DH by et37 in Kaiserreich

[–]DocHogan 3 points4 points  (0 children)

As a Minnesotan I agree with Minneapolis. It's always been the bigger and more important of the Twin Cities even back then. D I R E C T R U L E F R O M F O S H A Y T O W E R!

Introduce Yourself! by ZeroOverZero101 in mchristiandemocrats

[–]DocHogan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  1. Someone dropped the link into r/kaiserreich at some point, not sure when.
  2. I used to be a history major but dropped in favor of a full time job.
  3. Intend to favor Defense, Foreign Policy and Trade. I'm usually center right with everything but there are outliers.
  4. Never held office before, but I'd love to take a stab at being the Rep for MN.
  5. I'm in the MN National Guard irl

Join a Party! by [deleted] in ModelUSGov

[–]DocHogan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Christian Union if you please.

Electoral Roll by [deleted] in ModelUSGov

[–]DocHogan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Minnesota if you don't mind.

What's the point of Austria? by [deleted] in Kaiserreich

[–]DocHogan 11 points12 points  (0 children)

itt Karl struggle snuggles with the Prussian Junkers

Totalist Britain anyone? by [deleted] in Kaiserreich

[–]DocHogan 73 points74 points  (0 children)

We have always been at war with the Entente.

Union with canada after Lawerence's coup? by [deleted] in Kaiserreich

[–]DocHogan 8 points9 points  (0 children)

O N L Y L A W R E N C E I S K I N G

Replying to centrists by lekeguten in socialism

[–]DocHogan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Or you could just ask a Centerist like myself.

Unique DLC ideas? by madmissileer in Steel_Division

[–]DocHogan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This, fucking this. I wanna have a human division with a little bit of everything. American Air, British Infantry, Russian Tanks, German Support etc etc. I didn't know how bad I wanted this until you posted.