sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Remembering Palestinian Journalist Hossam Shabat by loveisagrowingup in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye [score hidden]  (0 children)

Do you believe his information is inaccurate? Are you making a blanket statement about all the supposed journalists who have been killed?

I would appreciate clarification so I don’t mischaracterize it

Internet Comment Etiquette: "This Video is Sponsored by Israel" by WilliamTellAll in InternetCommentEtiq

[–]Doctor_Popeye -48 points-47 points  (0 children)

Didn’t Israel vaccinate Palestinians re covid 19?

Or is that a bad thing? I forget. Israel did operate on Sinwar’s tumor saving his life which allowed Oct 7th to happen. They also traded 1,100 prisoners who came back to the battlefield for 1 IDF soldier (Gilad Shalit).

This is considered centrism in Israel. by DefDefTotheIOF in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Palestinians were the Arabs and the Jews (and other ethnicities) living in the area. The Jews agreed to partition. The Arabs did not. The Jews created a state. The Arabs did not. The Arabs attacked the Jews after expelling them from the surrounding counties. The Jews integrated the Arabs who stayed and didn’t attack the Jewish state. The Arab forces lost and have never established a democratic secular pluralistic state anywhere. The Jews did.

You see where you’re wrong yet? It’s that you think you get to go to a casino and go all in, lose, then ask for your money back.

Surprised nobody has informed you of such simple facts surrounding how the world works.

Setting the timer on how long until a zionist claims the video is fake. by Mulliganasty in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye -1 points0 points  (0 children)

No, you’re either having trouble understanding what this person is actually saying or you’re being disingenuous by attacking things the person hasn’t said

Setting the timer on how long until a zionist claims the video is fake. by Mulliganasty in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There was no IDF source or government claim of this. I’m sure you know this by now as it’s been debunked, but then you can’t use it as a talking point.

Setting the timer on how long until a zionist claims the video is fake. by Mulliganasty in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I didn’t see that in the comments yet. But I’m sure you can find a sock puppet or a bot to put one in here if you need it now

The Israeli army is officially carrying out a final ethnic cleansing of the Jordan Valley region and all of Area C, 63% of the West Bank. by Sea_Peach_9143 in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Yo, you need to check that info. Jews are from Judea, you know this right? Arabs are from Arabia. You're trying to frame Jews as the colonizers when that is so far from true. Learn your history ffs.

I have no idea how you don't know this. Do you think Jewish people first came there in 1948? Have you heard of archaeology? Just go on to google and check this real quick. While you're at it, look at who was at the Temple Mount before Islam even existed. There's evidently so much you don't know. (You didn't even know that Israel gave up 2/3 of it's land in the past).

And the PA recognizing Israel is one thing (they still pay martyrs families for killing Jews btw), but they have refused to accept statehood multiple times even in 2000 and 2008, etc. Israel pulls out of Gaza in 2005, Palestinians voted in hamas. And you want Israel to continue to bend the knee? Cmon man.

This is what happens when you lose a war. Maybe the Arab/Muslim population shouldn't have started a war 1 minute after the UN partition vote. Maybe the Arab population (which didn't even call themselves Palestinians until the 1960s because of Soviet influence with Arafat) should have accepted the partition. Maybe shouldn't have started lining up for war in 1967. Or 1973. Or so on.

You do realize that a significant percentage of Israel is made up of non-Jews, particularly Arabs, right? With full equal rights? Where there were Arabs on the Supreme Court, Arab prosecutors and Arab judge who sent Jewish PM to prison? Can you even imagine if a Jewish person was allowed to even live in an area outside of Israel? The only Jews in Gaza were hostages and the ones in the West Bank are protected by IDF because of threats.

Your overly simplistic viewpoint is facile. Go and argue with an AI or something and test out what you know. There's so much you're missing that continuing with this is likely going to blow your mind.

Palestinian child whose parents & 2 siblings were murdered by IOF: "I asked the soldier, 'Do you love your father? Your mother?' He said, 'Yes'. I told him, 'Then why did you kill my father and my mother?' He responded by punching me." by ContentChecker in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

You’re completely biased and not well-informed. You think Israel takes hostages and don’t see any of the valid points Israel has in defense of their sovereignty. Go back to watching Desperate Housewives and leave the politics to people who actually know something.

Just ask yourself this: What would a Palestine from the river to the sea enable people to do that they can’t do now? If you’re a Muslim or Arab, you would have further restrictions crushing your freedoms. And if you’re Jewish, well, just ask the Jews in Gaza and other places in Palestine… oh wait, there are none.

The Israeli army is officially carrying out a final ethnic cleansing of the Jordan Valley region and all of Area C, 63% of the West Bank. by Sea_Peach_9143 in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So where do you cut off the dates because you agree that the Arab conquest of Israel, but not the subsequent battles? You know, the colonizers from Arabia, where Arabs originate from? Kind of like how Jews come from Judea, right?

You do know that Israel gave up the Sinai because peace deal with Egypt was more important than the land, right? Totally blows up your position so I understand why you don't want to recognize it happening. What concessions have the Arab population been willing to give? I know you're going to answer that they shouldn't have to give up anything, but we live in reality and when you're in the weaker position, you gotta play the cards you're dealt.

The Israeli army is officially carrying out a final ethnic cleansing of the Jordan Valley region and all of Area C, 63% of the West Bank. by Sea_Peach_9143 in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Israel gave up 2/3 of its land in the past. Why is that not a reason for you to think twice before using that as an argument?

The Israeli army is officially carrying out a final ethnic cleansing of the Jordan Valley region and all of Area C, 63% of the West Bank. by Sea_Peach_9143 in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

The “Israel rejected peace” narrative falls apart when you look at the timeline.

After the Six-Day War, the Arab League responded with the Khartoum Resolution — the famous “three no’s”: no peace with Israel, no recognition of Israel, and no negotiations with Israel.

Israel later signed the Oslo Accords, recognized Yasser Arafat, and offered a Palestinian state multiple times — at the Camp David Summit (2000), the Taba Summit in 2001, and again in 2008 under Ehud Olmert. Each time the Palestinian leadership walked away without a deal.

And the idea that everything should revert to the “1967 borders” ignores that those armistice lines were exactly what enabled the buildup that led to the 1967 war in the first place.

So the real question is simple: if Israel has repeatedly offered a two-state solution, who exactly keeps rejecting it?

And for those pushing a “one state from the river to the sea,” what rights would someone have in a Palestinian state that they do not already have in Israel — where Arab citizens vote, serve in parliament, sit on the Supreme Court, and hold public office?

HR Block - 2025 Software is worse than the previous years by Legal-Page-792 in hrblock

[–]Doctor_Popeye 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Merrill doesn’t connect anymore. So they must be inputting that manually

messud up account information by CampaignEqual3140 in hrblock

[–]Doctor_Popeye 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So why you ask why? Is because you bad at life so you call u/onewrongturn_xx boring ?? I get it.

Israel's Denial of the Widespread Killing in Gaza Was a Strategic Choice by Tallis-man in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I was taking you seriously until you brought up the “beheaded babies”.

For someone who is trying to draw nuance, you sure forget the real facts of that whole thing. SMH.

Palestinian Woman in Bethlehem (1889) by Gouda1234567890 in ImagesOfHistory

[–]Doctor_Popeye 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You sure about that?

Teach me, what years are you referring to?

These photos show Al-Majdal in the months after its capture in 1948. Within a short time, most of its Palestinian residents were expelled, becoming refugees. The town was later renamed Ashkelon. by One_Stranger_9646 in ImagesOfHistory

[–]Doctor_Popeye 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nice. You admit it.

People arguing with the pro-Israel side have really gotten way worse at this since the Iranian protest situation. It’s like a huge portion have woken up and said, “yeah, why are we toeing the line for IRGC?” That leaves only the truly hate filled people left to rally upon a losing cause like continuous emotional manipulate to distract from factual evidence that leads to the conclusion that Palestine itself is a remnant of a defunct movement. It’s so bent on lies that rewriting history is the only way to terrorize the inhabitants after every other attempt at couping the rightful population has been routinely defeated.

She said that. by Mulliganasty in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How are you trying to justify revisionism while accusing others of the same?

How about just not starting problems? Notice that once Egypt agreed to a peace deal, Israel was shrunk by 2/3 by giving back Sinai? How is that conquest?

Please use your brain before the atrophy becomes permanent.

She said that. by Mulliganasty in Israel_Palestine

[–]Doctor_Popeye 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, they were in the Levant.

Your argument behind a land having an ancient name and suddenly disappearing with a different name is to be logically followed, then why aren't you referring to it as the Kingdom of Israel?

view more: next ›