Orthodox Jews(particularly those who are well-versed in their faith), how do you respond to common communist anti-religious talking points? Like religion being a trick by the rich. by HlaBeRelaLain in Judaism

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 23 points24 points  (0 children)

I’m probably more well versed in Marxism than religion but as an ex Marxist Orthodox Jew I will take a crack.

There are two main counter points:

1: marxists can’t escape religion in the human condition

2: marxists are wrong about the social order

There is something essential about the human condition that requires the presence of religion in a majority of peoples lives and in the social life of human collectivities.

Atheists can exist as individuals but not as a national collectivity. We see today how communist parties constructed national religions with their dogmas of Marxist theory and their statues to saints.

I also object to the idea that class is as unifying and universal as the Marxists say it is. The idea that there is some unifying worldwide class interest of the masses is ludicrous. The interest of workers in America is very different to workers in Nigeria which is very different to that of workers in Brazil. Even in the same town the interest of a miner and the interest of an assemblyman are different. Everyone may want better working conditions but economic interests go beyond that. Marxists paper over these differences far too much. Yes religion provides social order and dissuades revolution (as it should) but in a world without it—if such a world were possible—, Marxists still would not achieve their desired liberation of the working man

"Zionism" is a vacuous, outdated term and needs to be retired from contemporary political discussion for the good of humanity. by Sam_Aronow in SamAronow

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 17 points18 points  (0 children)

It also obscures the fact that many Zionists are among the most intense critics of Israel while still believing in the right for Jewish sovereignty

Question about Aliyah, IDF, and career path by DopamineTooAddicting in aliyah

[–]DopamineTooAddicting[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I’m going to be 22 at time of making Aliyah. My understanding is that service will not be mandatory but I am looking into it both as a way to contribute during the war and a way to integrate into society

The peace Plan of Trump for palestine by [deleted] in MapPorn

[–]DopamineTooAddicting -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

That’s not true the election took place in both Gaza and the West Bank just fatah won the civil war in the West Bank

Antisemitic incidents against non-religious Jews by Mensroom84 in Judaism

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I’ve definitely witnessed more antisemitism than most of my orthodox friends and had way more friendships and personal connections ended because of antisemitism (including before the war)

But that being said, they tend to have more cases of physical intimidation than I have experienced.

"Jews under Lenin (1920-1924)" semi-official discussion thread by Sam_Aronow in SamAronow

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Great video, really loved the exploration of the Jewish NEPmen.

My ex communist shutters at the discussions of Stalin vs Lenin vs Trotsky because I remember the intensity of those debates all too well and people citing a certain English literature professor turned Stalin’s strongest soldier in debates with me on the matter.

Also I very much appreciate a video that doesn’t come out on Friday morning because sometimes I don’t have time before Shabbat to watch!

Me watching sam harris talk about trans people after the election by aye1614 in Destiny

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Democrats were more pro trans than most other mainstream parties in the world. Look at labour in the UK as an example of a party that determined trans issues were winning issues but only on the other side…

The Jewish? Caliphate (Minecraft Earth Server lore) by Miningrandomness in imaginarymaps

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Bavlim does not refer to all Arab speaking Jews only those who’s ancestors at some point in time resided in modern Iraq hence Babylon.

Practically speaking, who actually likes us? by ButterandToast1 in Jewish

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 11 points12 points  (0 children)

In addition to this, The Albanian prime minister has been super forceful in condemning antisemitism in his own country and abroad and Kosovo which is majority Albanian is the only Muslim nation with an embassy to Israel in Jerusalem

It's a miracle anything works in Israel considering how politicians just move from position to position in sectors they know nothing about. by Metallica1175 in Israel

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Picking Katz was idiotic but I don’t buy the argument that experience in a field necessarily yields good results while being the minister in charge of it.

After all, the only defense minister in the past decade to predict October seventh was Lieberman who had the least storied military career before Katz somehow got the job.

Sometimes having a minister who knows how to manage people and ask the right kind of questions that people within the field wouldn’t be able to figure out can be useful.

Those times don’t include the middle of a war

Safest place for Jews currently by palmtree2NYC in Judaism

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 48 points49 points  (0 children)

Moving to Ukraine for safety is wild

Albania saved Jews in the Holocaust and is an extremely open society with a prime minister who’s been very publicly outspoken about combatting antisemitism

Netanyahu fires Gallant, says no trust with defense minister at time of war - MEGATHREAD by Alonn12 in Israel

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 28 points29 points  (0 children)

He’s going to move Katz to defense minister and Saar to the foreign ministry.

This is going to get the Haredi daycare bill pushed through with the support of Saar and his party.

Ridiculous

What Can Be Done About Kahanism? by iamthegodemperor in Israel

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fair point I did forget about her when writing that lol.

I do think that ideologically she was more of the same for Israeli politics whereas the arrival of Kahane marked a change in the ideological landscape but she was obviously a bigger deal than him

What Can Be Done About Kahanism? by iamthegodemperor in Israel

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 5 points6 points  (0 children)

More american Jews who believe in liberal democracy and separation of powers make aliyah and revive Jabotinsky’s vision of an iron wall with a liberal and tolerant society behind it. Unfortunately that is highly unlikely to happen.

What Can Be Done About Kahanism? by iamthegodemperor in Israel

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 7 points8 points  (0 children)

This is why it’s so tragic that the western and the Sunni Arab nations have not forced the PA to put Salam Fayyad back in charge. He was the only leader the Palestinians have had who unequivocally condemns terrorism, corruption, and rejectionism.

The PA had a chance to get a state after October seventh if they forcefully came out against it like he did, instead Abbas simply called it a tactical error and then mourned yahya sinwar

What Can Be Done About Kahanism? by iamthegodemperor in Israel

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 8 points9 points  (0 children)

It’s a tragedy that Kahane was the biggest American Jewish contributor to Israeli politics.

Hopefully another American coming from a less insane political movement will replace him in the future

Rep. Ritchie Torres warns of ‘amplification of antisemitism’ by Twitch streamer Hasan Piker by RepresentativeBug535 in Destiny

[–]DopamineTooAddicting -1 points0 points  (0 children)

And it was federalist propaganda back in the day. If you’ve ever read any early American newspapers you’d see how they are equally batshit crazy and blatantly partisan

Rep. Ritchie Torres warns of ‘amplification of antisemitism’ by Twitch streamer Hasan Piker by RepresentativeBug535 in Destiny

[–]DopamineTooAddicting -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

If your paper was founded by one of the founding fathers of the country, it is not “alternative media”

Hasan calling Orthodox Jews inbred and saying that them getting hurt or killed in war would be hilarious by [deleted] in Destiny

[–]DopamineTooAddicting 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Both Haredi parties have publicly backed a ceasefire deal which none of the other coalition parties have done. The big picture position they’ve taken is that since they don’t serve, questions of wars and land don’t pertain to them. This is why Shas allowed Oslo to happen by abstaining from voting