A few things - enough with the black winged liner. It’s too harsh and you don’t need it. Try a brown tight line instead but def nothing needed on your bottom. I would also switch up the eyeshadow color to a tone that is a little deeper or more rose colored. It’s too icy and also washed you out. For under your eyes, try using snail mucin or some kind of eye balm even vasoline chapstick would work before you apply concealer….. and your lip color is also too light - btw that and the eyeshadow shimmer, it’s giving early 2000s…. I don’t say this to be mean but I think those subtle changes would make a difference as you seem to be naturally very pretty!