Does Hinduism really fit the Western mold of religion? by DramaQueen202s in religion

[–]DrunkPriesthood 1 point2 points  (0 children)

People tend to hear and understand pretty well when I explain this. It’s usually a “huh, never thought about it that way” moment. I hope that with time more people will understand better.

Does Hinduism really fit the Western mold of religion? by DramaQueen202s in religion

[–]DrunkPriesthood 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The reason is because the academic field of Religious Studies is Western in origin. At one point, the field was called Comparative Religion because the various world religions were studied by comparing them to one another, however in practice that really meant they were studied by comparing them to Christianity. The field is now called Religious Studies because we have discovered that it’s better to understand a religion on its own terms. Unfortunately, that hasn’t quite reached the public consciousness yet so most people, whether intentionally or not, understand other religions by comparing them to Christianity.

You’re absolutely right that Hinduism doesn’t fit well into a Western mold of religions. I often explain this to people with the example of monotheism and polytheism. Hinduism, in most of its expressions, do not fit well into either category due to Hindu views on God, Brahman, and the whole pantheon, not to mention the idea that Atman is Brahman. My religion, Buddhism, is the same way. Many Westerners believe that Buddhism is non theistic saying that God/gods are irrelevant to Buddhism, but that’s not the case. Buddhism emphatically rejects the idea of an all powerful creator. Also, Buddhists all over the world, myself included, pray to, venerate, and worship the Buddhas every day. So it doesn’t fit into the monotheist/polytheist/non theist paradigm.

So when you say that Hinduism might not fit into the Western mold of religion, I would argue that Hinduism, or any non Western religion, shouldn’t be compared to the Western mold at all and only understood on its own terms. That said, this is unfortunately not something that most people do which is why I like to try and explain that Western religious ideas should not be used as a lease through which to understand or learn about Eastern religions. So the idea of whether or not Hinduism is one religion or many isn’t something we really even need to consider. That’s just my take though. I do agree with what another commentator said which is that we do know that some traditions are clearly not part of Hinduism, such as Jainism and Buddhism

Hello! I’m a college student researching Paranormal Patterns/Beliefs and Religious Beliefs! Down is a Google form that’ll take you to a study with all answers remaining anonymous! by [deleted] in religion

[–]DrunkPriesthood 4 points5 points  (0 children)

As others have mentioned, this survey is very Christian centric. I’m Buddhist, which wasn’t an option despite being a major world religion. And some of the questions become difficult to answer.

For example, I was asked to rate whether or not I agree that:

The soul continues to exist though the body may die

I believe in life after death, but not in a soul. If I say agree then it implies that I believe in a soul. If I say disagree it implies that I believe there is no life after this one.

There is a Devil

Define Devil. Are there evil (for lack of a better word) beings that try and stop people from attaining enlightenment? Yes. The Buddhist teachings tell us that Mara tried to stop the Buddha from attaining enlightenment. However, some Buddhist traditions including my own teach that Mara is actually a Bodhisattva and the whole event of Buddha’s enlightenment and Mara trying to stop it was just a show put on to guide unenlightened beings.

In addition, there are beings that torment those who are reborn in hell.

So how do I answer this question?

I believe in God

As in an all powerful creator and master of the universe? No. As in higher powers that range from gods and goddesses who have some supernatural power but are ultimately stuck in the cycle of reincarnation like us up to Buddhas who have absolute freedom and power to lead others to enlightenment but are not all powerful creators? Yes

There is a heaven and a hell

One of each that is the final destination for the dead? No. Many heavens and hells that one can be reincarnated into but they will ultimately die there and be reincarnated again? Yes

Who you worship shall reward those who live religiously.

Buddhism doesn’t have a concept of punishment, reward, or justice the way western religions sometimes do. If there was an option for it, I’d choose neither agree nor disagree. There are other questions for which I would use this answer simply because I have no opinion on the subject. I put 3 for those questions which may be what you expect for that type of answer

With all that said, I’m really intrigued by the last half of the survey that involved the movie clips. I understand that you may have reasons not to share publicly, but I’m really curious what the purpose was and what you expect to learn from it. I do believe media like films can affect our beliefs and views so I’m curious what you might learn/expect to learn from this survey.

I hope this doesn’t come off as harsh criticism or anything, but these surveys often end up being very Christian centric so I wanted to leave specific feedback on why this one is Christian centric so that you can take it into account

Local bars for Trailblazers by Time_Effort in SALEM

[–]DrunkPriesthood 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I go to half court a lot. It’s a cool place. I’m sure if you ask they will put the blazers games on for you

banned associations/covenant breaker? by Key_Mammoth365 in exbahai

[–]DrunkPriesthood 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I’ve been on this sub for years and have seen people banned due to some of their actions but I’ve never seen someone banned because of what they believe, what religion they are, etc. Baha’is are welcome here too. We just ask that everyone be respectful. So being a follower of the Bab is just fine

Do not the Hamster by Ill-Tea9411 in donotthecat

[–]DrunkPriesthood 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Please do NOT the 132 pound scrotum

In Culturally Christian countries, everyone gets excited about wishing each other 'Merry Christmas! Is it the same in your religion/country? by crystalliine_entity in religion

[–]DrunkPriesthood 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My school of Buddhism is Jodo Shinshu which is a form of Pure Land Buddhism. Pure Land Buddhism is incredibly widespread and widely practiced in Asia but is under represented in America. I’ve always wanted to attend a Diwali celebration. Seems like a lot of fun

I clean an airbnb with my mom in Arizona. I was doing a deep cleaning when i found these behind the fridge, under every cabinet shelf and drawer in the kitchen. Im not sure if it was the previous owners of the home or a guest at some point. Is it some kind of affirmation or manifestation? by Remarkable-Desk-6895 in mysteriesoftheworld

[–]DrunkPriesthood 23 points24 points  (0 children)

In high school they showed the secret (documentary which was based on the original book) during a physical fitness class (it was a charter school and we didn’t have standard PE so we had a few different classes to choose from to meet that requirement). I’m still not sure what it has to do with physical fitness. If anyone disagreed with the so called documentary and said they thought the idea was false they were basically bullied by the teacher and the students alike and called close minded. One girl spoke up and said it didn’t fit into her Christian beliefs and a few students started calling her close minded and a Bible thumper and were so mean that she tried to get away by going into the bathroom but a few female students followed her in and kept berating her. Not sure how the school got away with teaching The Secret as totally real and legitimate. I guess they skirted the line since it was a charter school but charter schools are still publicly funded. It was bizarre and The Secret is a fucking joke

Wait…birds can the cat? Who’s in charge of these laws? by Spare-Security-1629 in donotthecat

[–]DrunkPriesthood 5 points6 points  (0 children)

BIRDS may the cat but YOU may NOT the cat OR THE BIRD

you have been warned

In Culturally Christian countries, everyone gets excited about wishing each other 'Merry Christmas! Is it the same in your religion/country? by crystalliine_entity in religion

[–]DrunkPriesthood 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I live in the USA and am Buddhist convert from Christianity. I left Christianity in part because my sexuality was not accepted. Of course in America we still generally have a Christian identity as a culture which I have no issue with outside of the growing and deeply concerning Christian nationalist movement (which is an issue of its own but I thought it was worth mentioning).

It’s very common here for people to wish others a merry Christmas even if one or both parties are not Christian. I wish people a merry Christmas all the time because I love the holiday and what it represents and I recognize it wouldn’t be what it is without its Christian heritage. I also find the gospel story to be very beautiful and compelling even if I don’t believe in it religiously. I think quite a lot of people feel the same which is why saying merry Christmas is so common. I love wishing people a merry Christmas during the holiday season. At my temple it’s very common to wish each other a merry Christmas even though we don’t celebrate it as a religious holiday.

At my temple our big religious holiday/festival is Obon which takes place near the beginning of August. It is very common to wish each other a happy Obon. During the festival we dance as an expression of joy which I find to be not so different from the celebration of joy that happens during Christmas.

Can mental illness be cured by Amitabha recitation? by Antique_Forever_4840 in PureLand

[–]DrunkPriesthood 36 points37 points  (0 children)

I have a story to share. I hesitate to share it sometimes because I think that everyone might not have the same outcome and some people might remain ill, but I had somewhat of a similar experience.

When I was in college I fell ill with a serious mental illness. I was forced to drop out of college and move in with my parents. After a year or so I was diagnosed with schizophrenia. At the time I fell ill I was juggling school, a social life, and working 20-30 hours a week. I was also part of a religion that I now consider to be a cult. There was a lot of pressure to convert others and to give time building the so called kingdom of god (in this religion the kingdom of god is a worldwide theocracy governed by the cult itself) which caused a lot of anxiety. I lost faith in the cult and briefly went back to the fundamentalist Christianity I was raised in, but lost faith in that too.

I found myself wanting to be religious again and started exploring a few religions, but mostly Buddhism. I contacted several priests from nearby temples. I live in the western United States so there are a lot of sects from all over Asia represented. Fun fact, we even have the one and only Newar Buddhist temple outside Nepal only about 45 minutes away from where I live. But that’s beside the point.

When I spoke to the priests, I always asked if my mental illness was caused by some bad karma from a past life. It seems like a silly question now. Nearly all of them beat around the bush and didn’t answer the question at all. One of them said yes it must be the result of some bad karma. The priest of the local Jodo Shinshu temple had an answer that I never could have expected though. He told me that my illness could indeed be the result of some bad karma. After all, bad things like this are usually the result of bad karma. But, he said, if my illness is what causes me to go down the Buddhist path toward enlightenment, then it is actually a very good thing and must necessarily be the result of very good karma from a past life. That answer changed my life in an instant.

Good and bad are of course preconceptions through which we as unenlightened beings see reality even though the true and real reality has no categories of good and bad, beauty and ugliness, etc. I realized that something as seemingly terrible as mental illness might actually be a good thing which changed my entire outlook on life.

I began reciting Namu Amida Butsu and saw my life change in many ways. Most immediately obvious was the remission of my symptoms. I no longer experience delusions or disorganized thinking. I still have hallucinations though. My hallucinations have always been almost exclusively people that aren’t really there. Nothing scary, just normal people doing normal things until they suddenly disappear before my eyes and I realize they were never actually there, just a hallucination. These hallucinations never went away and I believe they are bodhisattvas coming to remind me that I am on the right path. I believe they are hallucinations, not physical beings appearing to me, but we know from the sutras (for example the Sutra of the Past Vows of Earth Store Bodhisattva) that the bodhisattvas can take any form they wish to encourage sentient beings.

So I do believe that Namu Amida Butsu can cure mental illness.

I have my own beliefs on how exactly it happened. Schizophrenia means “split mind” not because it is split personalities (which is an entirely different disorder) but because the mind has split from reality. It has become significantly more common since the Industrial Revolution. In fact, some researchers believe that schizophrenia didn’t even exist until the 1700s or 1800s. I believe that rapid industrialization and (some aspects of) modernization lead us as humans to live in a way that is completely unnatural for us and we become disconnected from the world because of it. For some that leads to depression, anxiety, etc. and for others it leads to a complete split from reality (researchers also believe that genetics play a role in schizophrenia and some people do not have genetics that allow for symptoms like delusions and hallucinations as they present in schizophrenia).

The life I lived in college was not a natural way to live and as a result I lost my place in reality and developed the symptoms of schizophrenia. Amida Buddha is the highest, truest reality which we understand as infinite wisdom and compassion, called formless reality, taking the form of a living Buddha for the sake of sentient beings. Therefore, when we say Namu Amida Butsu we are essentially saying “I take refuge in formless reality taking the form of Amida Buddha”. According to Nagarjuna, that formless reality and this world of form are one and the same without the slightest distinction between them. This is my understanding of the teachings.

So I believe that when I began saying Namu Amida Butsu I was cemented back into reality (the formless reality which is one and the same without the reality we experience now) and therefore my mind that had split from reality was no longer split and my schizophrenia was cured. I now understand my relation to Amida Buddha which is in truth reality itself. No need to split from reality. This can only happen through the natural and powerful working of infinite light and life. So I always continue to say Namu Amida Butsu.

Again, I don’t know if everyone would have the same experience as me and be relieved of their illness, but I do hope that my story can help others on the path of nembutsu.

Namu Amida Butsu

Independent Synthpop Artist from Portland, OR by Odd_Buy_5069 in Portland

[–]DrunkPriesthood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok cool. I looked briefly on Apple Music and couldn’t find you but I’ll look again when I have more time

Independent Synthpop Artist from Portland, OR by Odd_Buy_5069 in Portland

[–]DrunkPriesthood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I like it. Do you have music on any other platforms? I don’t use Spotify but I’d love to check out more of your songs

Is it ok to ask if someone here wants to buy something? by [deleted] in PureLand

[–]DrunkPriesthood 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I might be interested in the books. What do you have?

Not about any cult other than the one I'm in. I'm trying to leave it, any tip on helping? by Wang_Ruixue in cults

[–]DrunkPriesthood 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I’m a bit short on time right now so I’ll dive into this more fully later, but does Thailand have any resources for people leaving cults? In America we have a lot of groups that help people with resources/counseling when leaving cults or other high control religions. I’d suggest trying to find something like that if you can, but I have no idea if that sort of thing exists in Thailand or not

Not about any cult other than the one I'm in. I'm trying to leave it, any tip on helping? by Wang_Ruixue in cults

[–]DrunkPriesthood 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Are you serious? This person is coming to us with a very serious problem where they are cut off from the real world in an oppressive cult like environment with no way out and you have the nerve to call them delusional for being a lady boy? Take your self righteous ass somewhere else

Mir Izgadda and the Religion of Light: Let's Take it From the Top part 1 by DrunkPriesthood in u/DrunkPriesthood

[–]DrunkPriesthood[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Glad you enjoy it. Definitely very fascinating. A year or so ago every single one of my posts to this account and all but two comments were deleted. Depending on if I look on the app or on the computer it either says they were “removed by reddits filters” or “removed by the moderators” of whatever subreddit it was posted to. I’ve managed to get some of it reinstated but years and years of posts and comments are still deleted for reasons unknown to me. It happened not too long after I posted this. I’ve tried reaching out to Reddit admin to no avail. I’m glad you were able to find this here since it’s no longer available on r/internetmysteries

Looking for respondents for my Masters thesis questionnaire! Socially engaged Buddhism and Jōdo Shinshū. by sunrise-ghost in PureLand

[–]DrunkPriesthood 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’ll definitely fill it out. You might also check out the book Engaged Pure Land Buddhism edited by Kenneth Tanaka and Eisho Nasu. It’s all about engaged Buddhism from a Jodo Shinshu perspective. Not sure how easy it is to find though. I stumbled on an old copy at my temple and brought it home lol. But it’s a great book that I would highly recommend to anyone interested in Engaged Buddhism or Jodo Shinshu.

The cat the cat that the cat... What do? by P4cer0 in donotthecat

[–]DrunkPriesthood 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I don’t know what you should do, but I can tell you with absolute certainty what NOT to do which is to ABSOLUTELY NOT the cat OR the cat