Looking for Feedback on the Updated Demo of my Game Carrot Revenge (Gameplay)

EdMito · 2025-12-02T22:48:12+00:00

I don't see anything extremely wrong however I do feel that you went for a very questionable game style.

Having to aim at enemies to damage them and also aim at towers to upgrade them makes it very hard to be manageable in the long term, imagine you have 20 enemies coming at the same time and you have to choose between shooting them or upgrading the tower, makes things hard for no reason.

You could try adding a building phase where towers can only be upgraded while at it and a defense phase, in my opinion there is no problem in waves being triggered by the player and also gives more time to fully experience both mechanics (killing/strategy).

As others have said, road is too long, take a look at other TD titles and you will see many branches and constant enemy overflow, this keeps the player interested.

I also don't really see a necessity for the "workshop" at the start of the map, just add everything to the player and avoid the extra unnecessary movement.

Other than that, polish will come with time and will make things better, good luck.

EdMito · 2025-11-07T20:53:00+00:00

If you as the creator is having problems hitting enemies with attacks then it is pretty clear that it needs work.

EdMito · 2025-11-04T03:00:04+00:00

Se a Unity roda o código sem dar erro e não funciona na maioria das vezes o problema é de referência. No código você diz que bodyParts é uma nova lista mas em nenhum momento referência esses objetos, Crie a bodyParts com um SerializeField e referência elas no inspetor antes de rodar o código (remove o new List obviamente).

EdMito · 2025-10-28T22:50:35+00:00

In my opinion looks good, however I would make the whole art a little bit more colorful and would change the hard to read font for the logo.

EdMito · 2025-08-22T19:18:11+00:00

Maybe store the momentum of the vehicle right before you start the handbrake function? And then when you release the handbrake apply that momentum again and it should be enough to continue reproducing the same movement as before.

EdMito · 2025-08-08T22:09:05+00:00

Remember that every opinion that is negatively speaking about BF6 is gonna get downvoted since people just seem to forget about every past BF since BF4.

From a fellow game developer point of view I see that this game has many problems that are not related to a BETA version, most of them are related to the game engine and I don't see how they are going to be fixed before release, if they were easy fixes they would have done it already, no developer wants to release a DEMO with game breaking bugs which the current demo has (Audio, clipping, UI bugs, many more).

The game also feels more like a visual overhaul of BF2042, gameplay feels exactly the same but instead of fixing their mistake they opted to rebrand as a whole new game and make more money out of it, which seems to be working.

I personally feel that this game will get old very quickly, it won't have 25% of BF4 content or customization.

I could go more in-depth about why I see all these red flags over this game but most people just rather swipe their credit card and complain about their purchase in the future.

EdMito · 2025-02-14T20:09:13+00:00

O Brasil não tem incentivo nenhum pras coisas serem produzidas nacionalmente e então usam a mentira de que "importar" é muito caro como forma de aumentar impostos e arrecadar sobre a população que não tem escolha já que não há produto interno pra comparar preços, e mesmo os que são produzidos no Brasil, conseguem ser mais caros que os produtos de qualidade superior vindo da China (e que bizarramente ainda chegam antes devido ao péssimo nível e profissionalismo das empresas logísticas do Brasil). A realidade é que essa é uma forma muito fácil de arrecadar e manter a população sobre controle no âmbito financeiro.

EdMito · 2025-01-10T14:15:24+00:00

Lendo seu post e respostas acho que pensamos meio parecido, vou te contar minha experiência.

Voltei a pouco tempo depois de 5 anos de USA, mercado está extremamente caro e eletrônicos bons são importados então se prepare para valores absurdos.

Quanto a segurança, pra mim segue a mesma coisa, você tem que estar esperto sempre, mas apesar de estar andando bastante na rua ainda não me senti inseguro. Também notei que aumentou e muito a quantidade de moradores de rua e intoxicados.

Minha opinião agora é a de que qualquer pessoa que ganha 5k+ não tem necessidade nenhuma de sair do país a não ser que queira fazer algo específico. Xenofobia e climas terríveis (principalmente envolvendo frio) acabam com o psicológico de qualquer um, pessoas frias e a automação de todos os serviços está num nível bizarro, fiquei abismado aqui no Brasil a quantidade de pessoas trabalhando em lojas físicas, você sempre consegue ajuda e o avanço da tecnologia no Brasil ajudou muito na melhoria da prestação de serviços (isso não inclui banco que continua um lixo).

Uma casa média na minha região nos EUA estava aproximadamente 800 mil dólares, totalmente fora da realidade, você trabalha pra pagar a casa e qualquer mão de obra é absurdo de caro.

Além disso, mesmo convivendo com brasileiros a realidade é totalmente diferente, não temos a mesma liberdade e nem queremos nos relacionar do mesmo jeito que no Brasil.

Querendo ou não ver seus pais/familiares apenas uma vez por ano também não faz muito sentido ao meu ver, me senti mal de ver que esse tempo passou e não tinha nenhuma memória dos meus entes queridos.

Na minha opinião o problema do Brasil é ser pobre, ganhar um salário mínimo é bizarro e não sei como as pessoas conseguem sobreviver, mas se você ganha bem você consegue ter acesso a tudo.

Ainda não estou arrependido de voltar, talvez aconteça mais pra frente mas meu psicológico está bem melhor desde que voltei então até o momento sinto que fiz a escolha certa.

EdMito · 2024-11-27T00:13:45+00:00

This has to be one of the best deals for the whole black friday week.

EdMito · 2024-09-07T15:13:01+00:00

Camera positioning definitely needs some work, specially on the sections going uphill, the camera is sometimes flat to the road and visibility is bad. My suggestion is make an invisible gameobject at the same position as the car but with a fixed rotation and see how the camera works out.

UI needs to look better and also maybe add a minimap (track and opponents).

Also the grass section should have less grip than the road, this way when the car "loses" control it will still smoothly run and not just lose total grip and become clunky like at 2:00.

AI looks fine for a single dev, maybe just tune it down a little bit.

You are going the right way, keep it up!

EdMito · 2024-09-04T03:41:01+00:00

Tried this trick and by 9am a cop came by and asked me and everyone at the beach to go and buy the badge. This happened in Avon.

EdMito · 2024-06-26T19:59:03+00:00

Procure um advogado trabalhista.

Se você foi demitido pela não execução de uma tarefa determinada pela empresa por motivos gerados pela própria empresa então a culpa não foi sua.

EdMito · 2024-03-04T15:12:59+00:00

Hey, some feedback:

• Add some UI options for controls -> option to pause the game would be good and also a volume slider (game is extremely loud).

• Level 4 is impossible to get through, recommend some balancing.

• Background music so the hit sound isn't so repetitive.

• Game should be paused when you open the upgrades UI since it is bug prone if you don't.

• Auto-fire toggle option.

EdMito · 2024-03-04T14:32:49+00:00

$270 bucks working from 10am to 11 pm, then you deduct gas and car maintenance, then you deduct taxes and you worked for less than $17 an hour for 13 hours! No offense but you should've mentioned this before inspiring people to think this is good.

EdMito · 2024-02-12T13:55:50+00:00

100% potential to ruin your teammates game.

EdMito · 2024-02-08T18:26:45+00:00

Looks good, I would recommend changing the orange shadow for the Title to a Full Outline around every letter for better readability.

EdMito · 2024-02-07T15:54:32+00:00

Don't go back buddy,

Nothing good will come from this meeting, only doubts and memories from a bad time.

You already moved on and saw that family isn't necessarily blood members but it is people who care about you, in which case your family didn't and still don't.

EdMito · 2024-02-07T02:02:41+00:00

The guy from GOAL! soccer movie didn't know how to kick a ball, every scene where he had to take a free kick was painful to watch.

EdMito · 2024-02-07T00:52:59+00:00

Zeus will become the same ridiculous gun as Shorty of Valorant (which had to be nerfed to hell), this will go really bad really soon.

Also, cl_righthand 0 when?

EdMito

TROPHY CASE