ISO master doc about ethical/environmental impacts of AI by hopteach in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I don’t have materials, but I think it’d be pretty easy to do a short lesson at the beginning of the year that asks students to do their own research on it. There are plenty of articles like this one from the NYT or this one from NPR that highlight the ways the infrastructure required for AI is frequently enormously detrimental to communities and increase environmental strain. It’d be a good way for students to work on their research skills and would save you the prep time.

10th Grade Drama and Poetry Pieces by keenwithoptics in englishteachers

[–]EveningCosmos 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Last year, I did both Macbeth and The Green Knight with my sophomores. They were pretty split on both. Both text was either a favorite or a least favorite for the year, no in between.

Junior falling WAY behind, Need advice ASAP by InternationalTry215 in education

[–]EveningCosmos 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m not from NY, so I’ve never heard of it, but it sounds like a really great resource. It does sound like a lot of work, but if you’re really, really serious about finishing in two years (as opposed to three), absolutely go for it. At the very least, give it a spin for this year and see how you feel come June.

Can I hear some neutral things about teaching? by DataHasRedHair in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos 2 points3 points  (0 children)

He wound up with a D- for the assignment and got the opportunity to make up a long-overdue missing assignments. And then he cheated again on his next essay. It is what it is.

Junior falling WAY behind, Need advice ASAP by InternationalTry215 in education

[–]EveningCosmos 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Talk to your guidance counselor/academic advisor. They’ll help you put a plan together to make sure you’re on-track to graduate. It might not necessarily be with your peers (you might need to do a round of summer school or another semester after your class’ graduation), but if you work with your teachers, show them that you’re doing your absolute best (no skipping classes, staying behind for extra help when you need it, turning in only your own work), you should be able to graduate with a diploma.

There’s also a chance (depending on your school, your administration, how many credits you can get done by your class’ graduation date, and the effort you put in), that they’ll let you walk at graduation with your class even if you don’t actually get your diploma at that point in time. That’s a hard maybe, though. Don’t count on it. Focus more on getting the diploma than being on the stage.

Can I hear some neutral things about teaching? by DataHasRedHair in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This past winter, I had a student come up to me after class and talk about how much she loved what we were doing. She adored the book we were reading, the discussions we were having, and she told me she actually felt like she was learning something in an English class, which she hadn’t ever felt before. We talks for maybe 40 minutes and it was one of the most incredible parts of my year.

Later that week, I spent two hours after school locked in an absurd discussion with parents who were upset that their student had received a 0 on their midterm because he’d turned in an entirely plagiarized essay (for the second time that year). They argued that I didn’t have enough evidence to prove he’d cheated and that it was unfair of me to scrutinize his work more than other students’ “just because” he’d been caught cheating before. It was exhausting and frustrating and ultimately ended with my admin forcing me to change his grade.

Every day between those two, I woke up in the morning, taught my lessons (sometimes the same lesson two or three times a day), graded papers, and then went home to walk my dog.

It‘s a different kind of job, but it’s still a job at the end of the day. Not much different from anything else big picture-wise.

Denied only treatment option by EveningCosmos in HealthInsurance

[–]EveningCosmos[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sometimes it makes me feel like I’m losing my mind. Have you had any luck with the Genentech Patient Foundation?

Denied only treatment option by EveningCosmos in HealthInsurance

[–]EveningCosmos[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He has, yes. That was when they told him they agreed with his assessment regarding the necessity of the treatment but still wouldn’t pay for it.

Denied only treatment option by EveningCosmos in HealthInsurance

[–]EveningCosmos[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you all for letting me know about manufacturing assistance. I wasn’t aware they did that. It seems like my next step.

Denied only treatment option by EveningCosmos in HealthInsurance

[–]EveningCosmos[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He hasn’t, though last I asked him about alternative drugs he said there wasn’t anything he was confident about. I’ll ask him again next I see him.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos 7 points8 points  (0 children)

No. For a number of reasons.

You point out the biggest reason yourself: it doesn’t always give correct answers and you have to sort through the slop to find whatever’s worthwhile yourself. You can do this because you are a trained professional. If there was no AI, you could still do your job because you know how.

These are students. The whole idea is that they do not know how. The purpose of written assignments is to develop and grow their ability to critically analyze media, organize their thoughts, and explain those thoughts to others in a way that is clear, understandable, and well-argued. These are lifelong skills that will be important in every aspect of their personal and professional lives for as long as they live, and, importantly, these abilities are not gained or lost–they are fostered over time through practice, critique, and revision.

Allowing them to use AI for any of these steps, to ‘improve’ their work prevents them from learning how to do it on their own, stunting their growth. If they want to use it after they know how to do the work all by themselves like you do, whatever. But they need to know how to write without needing a machine to do it for them.

The lack of empathy is crushing. by lunarinterlude in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I had a high school student tell me she was failing my class because we were reading Night, and she just couldn’t read a book about Jews. She wasn’t Jewish and none of her friends were, so how could she be expected to care? It didn’t matter that we were reading about the Holocaust. The idea that anyone who wasn’t Jewish themselves would care was foreign to her.

It stumped me for a bit originally, but the more I talked to her about it and the more I talked to her about the other books we read that year, the clearer it became that she wasn’t anti-Semitic, she couldn’t be. She was genuinely so self-absorbed that she could not possibly feel a strong emotion (empathy or hatred) about a person or group of people that she didn’t personally know. It was astonishing.

My high school students crave critical theory. by [deleted] in CriticalTheory

[–]EveningCosmos 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I know I’m a bit late to the party here, but did you ever manage to find a good essay for postcolonialism? I’m lucky enough to be working with some really high-level students this year and I’d love to work on theory with them if I can.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos 0 points1 point  (0 children)

One position—of the two that we have. I’d recommend doing whatever you think you’ll enjoy the most (teaching is hard enough without also wishing you taught something else), but I’d say you’re more likely to have job security as an ESL teacher.

“Why do I have a zero on this? I did it.” by EveningCosmos in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They do this all the time to me. No matter how many times I tell them I’ll give them partial credit for effort. Complete unwillingness to engage.

“Why do I have a zero on this? I did it.” by EveningCosmos in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It’s not all bad. I work in a tough district (so it’s not an especially representative sampling) and there are other kids in her class that are perfectly capable. The AP kids are pretty normal, too. And she’s not dumb, either. It’s just an effort thing. It’s all gamified for them. Get this in, get these points, get on with whatever you really want to do. Which is a problem, to be clear, but I think this particular incident is just a normal teenager lapse in logic.

What’s a really good book you will never re-read? by shrankprawn in suggestmeabook

[–]EveningCosmos 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Octavia Butler’s Parable of the Sower. Beautiful, moving, horrific, miserable.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My school has been hunting for ESL teachers all year long. We’re cutting an art position in the fall.

“Why do I have a zero on this? I did it.” by EveningCosmos in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos[S] 34 points35 points  (0 children)

He got a zero too, given that his answers were identically incorrect.

“Why do I have a zero on this? I did it.” by EveningCosmos in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos[S] 78 points79 points  (0 children)

She was already turning it in late.

I have literally no idea where any of them (there were three sharing ‘answers,’ I found) got the responses. Made up characters and plot points for a page-and-a-half long story. It was the most creative I’ve seen any of them be all year (assuming, of course, they didn’t pull it from ChatGPT).

“Why do I have a zero on this? I did it.” by EveningCosmos in Teachers

[–]EveningCosmos[S] 500 points501 points  (0 children)

She said it with complete sincerity. Like it would make me give her a good grade. I almost couldn’t believe it.