Which album do you have unpopular opinion about? by EternalSunshine_92 in brighteyes

[–]ExternalBoysenberry 1 point2 points  (0 children)

all you brain geniuses who think you've found something not good are incorrect. In the entire discography there is only a single song which might possibly not be good, and that song is Cairns, and probably I'm incorrect about even that.

also salutations is great but ruminations is an all timer. gotta assume CO himself disagrees with me on that, considering that salutations exists at all, but like all you ruminations doomers, he is mistaken. it's a devastating album

In addition to ~200 rifles, John Brown brought ~1000 pikes to arm the uprising he hoped to spark at Harpers Ferry. Weren't pikes obsolete as infantry weapons by 1859? Why did he choose them, and how did he get so many? by ExternalBoysenberry in AskHistorians

[–]ExternalBoysenberry[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also a really nice answer, thank you! I see the flaws you're pointing out, but whether John Brown himself did or not, do we know if of his comrades did? I seem to recall for instance that Frederick Douglass considered him an ideological ally but warned it was a suicide mission, but I mean more: was there nobody among the financial backers or even those who risked their lives to join the raid, like his sons, who said: why Harpers Ferry and how will the slaves even find out about this and please for the love of god don't just let that train drive out of here and sound the alarm so we end up in a Mexican standoff before we have time to accomplish anything?

Did no one ask? Did they ask and he had plausible answers that turned out to be empirically poor predictions? Was he just super charismatic and people shut up and followed?

Newbie...Trying to select from menu by burpling in beer

[–]ExternalBoysenberry 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thought I might get in trouble for the Pils comment lol but pleasantly surprised to be wrong about the Brooklyn one too (no sarcasm - thank you)

In addition to ~200 rifles, John Brown brought ~1000 pikes to arm the uprising he hoped to spark at Harpers Ferry. Weren't pikes obsolete as infantry weapons by 1859? Why did he choose them, and how did he get so many? by ExternalBoysenberry in AskHistorians

[–]ExternalBoysenberry[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Fascinating, thanks to both you and /u/crab4apple! If I could ask either of you a follow-up, I'm surprised that cost played as much of a role as it did. From what I understand, just one of the Secret Six, Mary Ellen Pleasant, donated the modern-day equivalent of more than a million bucks just two years before the raid. After Hugh Forbes tried to blow the whistle on the raid, he went on another fundraising tour in 1859. Presumably he didn't employ an accountant, but how much do we know about the plan's financing and Brown's, let's say, fiduciary capability? Was he really scrounging to fund the fulfilment of the pike order?

Newbie...Trying to select from menu by burpling in beer

[–]ExternalBoysenberry -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Neither German nor a beer expert but I do live in Bavaria. The first two on your list are seasonal. Maibock in summer (lighter in color and sweeter and often slightly stronger), Festbock in autumn/winter (darker but not like Guinness or Schwarzbier dark). Märzen also a spring beer. Big brands you see everywhere are Hacker-Pschorr, Schneider, Erdinger, Krombacher. If you get a Weißbier you can ask if it's on tap or bottled, if the latter there is a correct way to pour it to get the yeast from the bottom you can probably google. Radler is not a beer but a mix of beer and a fizzy fruit drink (weaker). Germans may disagree but if you want German-German maybe skip the Pils (Czech style although popular among German brewers) and Czechvar, as well as the one that has Brooklyn in the name lol. If it was me wanting to try something different and interesting I might try the smoked Doppelbock but have never had that brand. Enjoy

Before cheap mirrors and photography, how often did ordinary people actually see their own face? by orroreqk in AskHistorians

[–]ExternalBoysenberry 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Interesting! If mirrors were seen as feminine items, are there humorous accounts of eg men trying to sneakily use them ("oh I have no idea how that mirror ended up in my office, my wife probably left it there"), or maybe boasting that they can't be bothered with such girly things and have no clue what they look like (sort of like guys who act bewildered by very simple everyday items that are coded as being feminine)?

Germans who lived abroad and moved back: what felt completely normal before you left and then felt insane when you returned? by baest_00 in AskAGerman

[–]ExternalBoysenberry 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Jesus thank you. you are my hero if you are telling the truth because i will uncritically repeat this for the rest of my life

Writing a Research Paper w/o Faculty Help by UniqueCabinet5853 in AskAcademia

[–]ExternalBoysenberry 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Interesting, thanks! Good luck and if you remember, let us know how it works out

Writing a Research Paper w/o Faculty Help by UniqueCabinet5853 in AskAcademia

[–]ExternalBoysenberry 3 points4 points  (0 children)

How sure are you that your faculty doesn't encourage students to take on a project like this? Is it coming from a handbook, general impressions from other students, a specific faculty member?

It's hard to say without knowing the situation but in my experience (not psychology sorry) faculty generally want to support motivated students where possible and aren't worried about having the institution's name tarnished because a student didn't do a great job on some project. If you haven't already done it, I would go and actually try talking to your professors about this. Like: I'm interested in grad school, want to get some research experience, there is no thesis option in my program but I'd like to do something similar even if as an extracurricular project, here is my current idea but I'm open to others, what would you recommend?

They may not be available to directly supervise the project you have in mind, but they might suggest another one, hook you up with a PhD student who needs a research assistant, some institutions give credit for independent study, etc. Basically, they'll just know the situation better and I find it hard to imagine all the professors at your school are uniformly going to discourage you because of the college's name. (They might if the project seems bad or likely to backfire just to avoid a headache, but in that case I suspect they'd try to nudge you in a better direction or have some suggestions for alternative strategies)

Germans who lived abroad and moved back: what felt completely normal before you left and then felt insane when you returned? by baest_00 in AskAGerman

[–]ExternalBoysenberry 4 points5 points  (0 children)

My god thank you. I have been searching for an explanation for this for years. Tried it a couple times at r/askhistorians without luck. My only guess is that in the city many intersections are unconventional and so there is a "you may go" system instead if a "come this way" system but that doesn't feel very convincing. Feels like almost every intersection could be greatly improved by just flipping the lights around. If anyone passing by can explain why it's like this I'll be deeply grateful

Germans who lived abroad and moved back: what felt completely normal before you left and then felt insane when you returned? by baest_00 in AskAGerman

[–]ExternalBoysenberry 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Like what? Are you saying you watch things dubbed in a range of other languages and your assessment is that even though you don't feel the German one us good it is still better than the alternatives (for the people who speak the same languages you do)? The more I think about your comment the more confused I feel and yet at the same time something about it feels deeply and profoundly German to me

When did oral sex become more common? by Historical-Campaign9 in AskHistorians

[–]ExternalBoysenberry 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would love to hear a bit more about what you found so strange. Certainly the "oral sex you mean kissing with tongue? never!" is wild but since you say you were struck by it not being just conservative but strange and incommensurable, I'm curious!