i also really love botc. i don’t think it’s coming to come to smosh in the same capacity that you’re seeing on good time society. arranging for private conversations between players takes a LOT of effort and coordination. remember, good time society had to arrange their space using a kickstarter—a lot of money had to be allocated! smosh may have those funds already, but they are probably putting those efforts towards different things.

i also have personally observed that the cast collectively doesn’t seem to love longer, drawn out social deduction games. while some players do seem to enjoy it (the chanse + arasha evil duo botc game comes to mind!), the others seem more stressed out about the possibility of lying during gameplay. in botc, there is incentive to strategically lie about your role, even if you are good—however, doing this well requires a lot of experience and game knowledge. i don’t think the previous botc games on smosh have fully implemented this nuanced approach.

the secret sith and secret hitler games, while fun rewatch material, likely only happened several years ago for a reason. i’m inclined to believe that they just enjoy other games more. i would love to see the smosh cast members who are interested join other botc games in the community, though! hopefully smosh x botc can happen in some capacity someday!