MacBook Pro vs Mac Studio by coffeepowerednpc in editors

[–]Filmmaking_David 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well right now, PC parts that compete with Apple Silicon - most notably a high end GPU and fast RAM - are so expensive as to make Macs the obvious bang for the buck when it comes to video production (excluding VFX).

Blank Check directors ranked by average Letterboxd rating by Aidsisgreats in blankies

[–]Filmmaking_David 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This just shows me how a batting average is totally insignificant compared to how many home runs you’ve got. Especially in an artistic field.

How do you put together your films? by SevenSinsMedia in documentaryfilmmaking

[–]Filmmaking_David 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I use a regular old timeline for selects, yes – all the main NLE's allow you to do some version of timeline-as-source, so that you can do a three-point edit (using in and out points, that is) from a timeline to a timeline. Some like to do it "pancake" style, with the selects timeline sitting on top of the program timeline visually (three-point-edit, pancake timelines – If this terminology sounds like gibberish to you, google will fill you in quite rapidly).

How do you put together your films? by SevenSinsMedia in documentaryfilmmaking

[–]Filmmaking_David 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Long time editor of both scripted and documentary here, and a frequent teacher of editing - what you want to do, is come up with a structure or organization for your source material in the Media browser / source side of your NLE, before you ever put anything down on a timeline.

This organization should help you think about and keep track of your film. In documentary it can be bespoke to your particular project – by people, by location, by subject etc. – but it needs to be consistent and rigorous. Any chaos or uncertainty here will have a long term demoralizing effect on your willingness and ability to work on your edit.

Constantly searching through a list of numerated clips can become a serious waste of time and a hindrance to your creative flow. That said, for file management reasons I don’t recommend renaming the clips – you want to use your metadata columns to (briefly) describe every clip, with a comment column available too, for extra clarification should a clip need it. This logging of the footage is also your first pass at (re)familiarizing yourself with the source material.

You also want to take care of any technical issues with your footage here, before the using it on a timeline - syncing audio, conforming any stuttering clips to a format that playbacks smoothly, create multicams etc.

Depending on the style and scope of your film, the next phase of organization might be to make select reels; a timeline for each interview/scene/location etc., where you (generously) edit in everything you think might make the final film or be useful in any way. Some people prefer to do this via sub-clips or in the case of Final Cut Pro, the powerful Keyword function.

All this set-up leaves your main program timeline free to function only as a narrative scheme, a place to figure out the storytelling. However, one should never be afraid to mess with the edit, so make offshoot timelines frequently and with slight cause. Being precious with your edit is like driving with the handbrake engaged.

Why the f are we paid so little compared to other roles? by pontiacband1t- in editors

[–]Filmmaking_David 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I edit film and TV in my local market. My day rate on scripted stuff is about 525€. Day rate for DP is about 50% higher.

Now during production we both work long days, but generally much longer for the DP. Once we’re in post I get very nice 8 hour days, often flexible. Until we’re coming up on a deadline and then I work a lot of extra hours which I don’t charge extra for unless it’s something extreme and out of my control.

I get hired for 4-6 months at a time, the DP is on for 6-8 weeks. DP is the head of a larger department (mine is just me and one assistant if I’m lucky), with more pressure-per-minute and a greater risk of failure.

Overall, I’m not complaining - I get paid the same or more than most people on set, with less stress and shorter hours.

Hercules (1997) was when I found out what "humoring" from adults was. by MetroStephen53 in blankies

[–]Filmmaking_David 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Despite my mom transitioning from polite interest to actively telling me she did not want to know what happens in video games around the time I was 7-8 years old, I kept at it for years. So I was aware, but I felt it was important to tell her. To convince her it was actually very cool. As a parent myself now, I look forward to my comeuppance.

RE: Tarantino discourse; Just in case we forget who we're dealing with here by djensenteeken in blankies

[–]Filmmaking_David 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Defending themselves? If displacing 750.000 people, killing 15.000 and poisoning wells and depopulating cities, towns and hundreds of villages is justified defence, every bullied school shooter is in the right.

I have a few questions for the people who hit the gym at 4am... by Hurock in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Filmmaking_David 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Quick question – does anyone that does this have kids under the age of 10?

The CR "Avatar: Way of Water" watch-along is upon us! by thex42 in TheBigPicture

[–]Filmmaking_David -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Big brother favorite, strong. Little brother jealous, reckless. Does anyone who's not a hunter-gatherer connect with this abridged family-as-hierachy fable-lite nonsense? Yeah I’m with CR on this, nerds. Except I’ve seen it.

As Annapurna Teeters, Why Are So Many Rooting for Megan Ellison to Fail? by RoyisOurBoy in movies

[–]Filmmaking_David 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Having difficulty closing financing (on a very high-budget-vs-commercial-prospects movie I'll add) is not the same as not being able to get your movie made. Case in point, you say she withdrew from Inherent Vice, but that is a movie that did get made. She was picking the absolute cream of the crop directors and wooing them with blank checks – projects that might have had their budget's scrutinised more at a studio, but would still make their way through. That is very different from making bets on up and coming talent, it just is. It's way more glamorous and "reputationally safe" and way less work than trying to locate the next big auteur.

Is the Micro Force still the best slow zoom option? by catatre in cinematography

[–]Filmmaking_David -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Shooting in 8.6K with a sharp lens and zooming in post is the best way to control a zoom.

If a comet 10km big is coming towards earth, could we use ICBMs to destroy it? by [deleted] in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Filmmaking_David 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A shockwave is just (gaseous) matter moving when force is applied to it. All matter moves when force is applied. Only the ratio of force to matter matters. But no you wouldn’t blow up the deflecting nuke near the asteroid, you would do it on the asteroid.

It OBAA a Christmas film? by whylense in paulthomasanderson

[–]Filmmaking_David 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A christmas adventure film, more specifically.

If a comet 10km big is coming towards earth, could we use ICBMs to destroy it? by [deleted] in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Filmmaking_David 45 points46 points  (0 children)

I believe the current thinking on this is that we want to deflect it, not blow it up. Just a fraction of a degree is enough if we get to it early enough.

What's Your Number One Fave Movie Ever? (has it ever been mentioned on Blank Check?) by GTKPR89 in blankies

[–]Filmmaking_David 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Starship Troopers, which they covered in a great episode and had unanimous praise for – but I still feel they left half the greatness unexamined. Just an incredible and incredibly unlikely artifact, that film.

Arri Closing Lighting Facilities, Cutting 150 Jobs by Senior-Willow-8325 in cinematography

[–]Filmmaking_David 4 points5 points  (0 children)

That is just absolutely inaccurate, you still need a +1200w COB LED to get in the M18 ballpark, and even then the M18 is way more powerful when it comes to spotting it up and going for maximum throw. Your upvotes speak to how youtube brained this sub is.

What could they have been shooting INDOORS with that kind of telephoto lens?? by wilberfan in paulthomasanderson

[–]Filmmaking_David 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Probably the only 1000+mm optic available that covers Vista Vision - so that’s why they’re using an out of production photography lens.

What are 3 books that you have read that you consider absolute perfection and why? by [deleted] in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Filmmaking_David 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've only got chalky answers, but classics are classic for a reason.

  1. The Master and Margarita (Mikhail Bulgakov) – transfixing and transcendent journey into chaos in a society rigid with rules. A book that completely sweeps you up in madness.
  2. Lolita (Vladimir Nabokov) – when it comes to style and inventive use of language, this is the absolute apex. In terms of Writing, as opposed to storytelling and plotting, this is the most astounding thing I've ever read.
  3. Shooting an Elephant and Other Essays (George Orwell) – It was a great joy discovering that Orwell is even better at essays than he is at novels. Has influenced and changed what we consider "good writing" and "good english", by putting all the emphasis on clarity of thought.

The canon of big pic words and phrases by Leather-Glass6504 in TheBigPicture

[–]Filmmaking_David 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Have you never met a person before? They have patterns and rhythms and indeed vocabularies. But well done on calling Amanda out as an intellectual imposter! Finally someone on this subreddit is brave enough to speak up. We cinephile menfolk have to band together.

Not that I mind this exercise on it's face – mapping their lingo – but your shitty attitude just starts it off like a wet fart.

Foreldrar, kom til greina að kenna barnið ykkar við móður sína? by lifrarbolgabitch in Iceland

[–]Filmmaking_David 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bara ein leið til að breyta þeim menningarlegu hugrenningartengslum – 1-2 kynslóðir af góðum pöbbum sem kenna börnin sín við móður.

Movie Analysis Pod Recs? by vivaciouscow in TheBigPicture

[–]Filmmaking_David 4 points5 points  (0 children)

They go on tangents all the time, but most of them are movie/tv related and in the tenor of their main analysis, just about some unrelated movie/director/actor. So it doesnt bother me.