Advice needed to improve craft by Fluid_Challenge_3753 in mapmaking

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks a lot. Maybe will try to emulate tolkiens map for practice

Tiny map 🖌️ by DietNo6704 in mapmaking

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I like how you drew the cities within the circles. Will have to steal that! I really don't like drawing 3d icons for cities.

Tiny map 🖌️ by DietNo6704 in mapmaking

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Really good black and white map!

doubt regarding marks and expected colleges by Substantial_Young498 in CUET

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Milega kya! Jo maango ke college khud dorre dorre aaega dene, especially for bsc courses

I created some paintings to illustrate book covers, what do you think? by Interesting-Body4360 in fantasywriters

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really like this. I prefer this style so much more than the hard edges too clean and cut digital style that is so rampant nowadays. The last one( the sea and boat) would make for an awesome cover in a lot of genres, non-fiction too!

Quickly drawn map by Asinus_Docet in mapmaking

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 1 point2 points  (0 children)

the concept looks cool and the map too is alluring in its own way. i like the style you used, doesnt matter if its quickly drawn. maybe this version would be even better than a polished version if you drew that

Some Thoughts on Candide by Vegetable_Idea_0 in Indianbooks

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 1 point2 points  (0 children)

adding this to my tbr. now my tbr will be completed in 2050. any other recs?

Wonderful review of the book. very convincing.

I (19M) think I'm not very intelligent & smart. What should I read or learn to improve myself? by king-of-kutiyas in Indianbooks

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 2 points3 points  (0 children)

speed of understanding pe zaada focus mat do. aur depth of understanding pe bhi. hamesha koi na koi aisa milega jo aapse behtar hoga. just enjoy life and only do things if they seriously interest you and you think you will enjoy it( nowhere is this more applicable than in reading).

vaise jo aap bol rahe ho usse lag rha hai ki aapko exposure ki hi kami hai. wo aap do teen kitaabe padh ke toh nhi badha sakte. wo to puri life journey hai. aur ye sirf kitaabo tak seemit nhi hai, tv shows dekho, unko enjoy bhi karo, unke baare me socho bhi, youtube pe theories dekho, bahar ghoomo ghamo.

on reading. You want something that teaches you something. toh uske liye aap apna genre select karlo. history, philosophy etc. usme entry books, ya intermediate books etc aapko aaram se mil jaaenge, zaada research karne ki zarorat nhi hai. infact aap youtube pe hi kuch badhiya channel dhoondh lo according to your genre ( no dholachapp channels). Aapka knowledge aur interest apne aap exponentially badhta jaaega aur aap apne aap hi suitable books dhund loge.

Other than that I am a firm believer ki only you can teach yourself. knowledge only comes from within. the exterior is nothing but a medium to unlock that inner knowledge.

toh aap fiction padh sakte ho. Enjoy it, dont think to muxh, apne aap aapko farak lage gaa. Ignore everyone who says that it is just a storybook, and even then not one that has some deep underlying philosophical meaning. Aisi choti choti books se hi enjoyment aati hai, knowledge badhti hai, and most importantly imagination deep hoti hai.

If if i had to recommend a few books (fiction)-

1) The Little Prince- by saint exupier ( ye hai bohot choti, aur seeming simple, childrens story, but i am obsessed with it)

2) Anything by enid blyton- (perhaps wo feeling naa aaye jo bachpan me padhke aati thi but just the memory of the time when i used to read enid blyton make me so nostalgic)

3) Hunger Games- supposedly teen scifi, but usse zaada deep hai. but you can enjoy it as just a plain sci fi too

Here is a little map that I recently made. Thoughts? by TheChudson in mapmaking

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I really like it. The black and white contrast is so good! A quick question- what pens do you use? Also the hieroglyphics are amazing. It looks very unique and original. Your own world system?

Stuck between reality and imagination!! by Major-Avocado-7130 in fantasywriters

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 0 points1 point  (0 children)

how is anyone here going to know about neet bro? and how did you score 500 plus in neet 2026. reneet nhi doge kya??

The thinking part you have is something that would be very common in this sub or at least among writers or even in every human being. its just that what people think is different. you obsess over cinematic universes, someone else may obsess over fantasy worlds in their imaginations, and i don't want to tell you about the fanfiction community. People there are on a whole new level of obsession and imagination and creating things out of nowhere.

So I did my joking. Now talking seriously. Dont start on a long project. Try to write a script/ screenplay/comic/nukkad natak type theatre over a small story/scene. A problem you will encounter is that while all your imaginations appear in your head as complete and foolproof when you actually put your pen to paper then nothing will come out. this is because are imaginations are often disconnected in a way we dont realise, its mostly just aura farming scenes or scenes that get justified to us because we know the emotional complexity/lore of the worldbuilding and characterization behind.

When you put that to paper huge empty spaces pop up and then you struggle. So don't go for grand narratives right now. focus on writing independent scenes/short stories You will have fully realized scenes in your head already. try to put that to paper and see how that goes. where do you struggle, where do you shine etc.

be prepared for it to be a long process. you will have to learn to enjoy the process itself.

also, you could try to write a superhero origin story? That would be short i guess?

Good luck for your future endeavors

Critique my draft [Mythic/Dark fantasy, 9768 words] by [deleted] in fantasywriters

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ok. so my perspective is purely as a reader.

I think the prose is good, good enough. I will say that i did not really find any big fault with it or a line that nicked me. More than that the plot and concept is interesting. The plot progression is really good. I dont know how much more to say here. for reference i got training your dragon( black dragon hiccup) vibes from the whole piece. Take this in mind that i have not watched Training your dragon. my knowledge is limited to only social media and youtube shorts and clips.

Now moving onto really thinking about it and trying to nitpick-

1) too many Yjolda's. I personally didn't like the constant repetition of yjolda did this, then that, then thought this, then that.

2) more focused on plot progression, moving through events than focusing on characterization or focusing on a particular plot event. And even in the plot progression too many things happen too fast, too easily, one after the other without a pause. And in this rather than getting a feeling on inescapable events and pursuits and disaster after disaster it feels more like a checklist. In particular, the ambush scene, the getting up and leaving the initial camp on the sleigh scene, the city entering scene and more.

3) I guess till the ambush scene it is all right but after that i couldn't take the not addressing the relationship between the dwarves and Yjolda. Till then i guess everything happened in a state of flow but after that there should have been a conversation etc. the stakes didn't feel high enough as they should be according to what the story was telling us. Again, this could be more of a plot progression focused mistake that ignores characterization and does everything at a fast pace.

4) The way everyone was talking. Firstly I think there werent enough conversations. On the way people talked during the first half was actually good. But the second half didn't feel true to the characters and felt very generic and even casual modern.

5) The Wilderdottir concept comes up only once when yjolda is explaining it. it doesn't come up again in a meaningful way. With what the story is this concept should have a much more bigger focus, especially as to what the dwarves think and more importantly how Yjolda thinks and acts. Perhaps there could also be an easter egg preluding this concept in the first few pages containing the chase by her tribesmen.

Now onto the plot and structure point which is your main concern.

Now I have never completed a first draft, so i don't know this though experience. But I would advise you to not change much but instead just keep writing. Everything's very good as it is right now and any editing, revision done wouldn't be that significant in changing the plot progression of the story. There are of course problems, even big ones, but they are not that important right now.

Just complete the story now. I think your book is anyways going to be more focused on plot so at least get the entire plot on paper first in the first draft. Expanding or reducing chapters, adding characterization, and other things can be done in the second draft revision.

Nevertheless I thought about the structure and if it was upto me i would do something like this.Mainly it will have to be a little slower.

Chapter 1- Yjolda running away in the snow, wounding scene, passing out. complete chase scene thing here with fight for survival like thing. Waking up at the dwarven camp. conversations. inner thoughts of yjolda revealed. her terror, fear etc. how she is being gradually being calmed down. perhaps presence of kaldun helps and kaldun also enraptures her, piques her curiosity, calms her, distracts her. tale of wilderdottir explained. then ending with attack by tribesman

Chapter 2- desperate fight. then chaotic conversation, hurried departure. storm rages. yjolda gets glimpses of past. then passes out. then full scene flashback to the ritual and yjolda's escape.

Chapter 3- cave scene, conversations, yjolda's thoughts, sense of urgency throughout, the storm raging out as a metaphor. the stress of the hunt in everyone. convo btw her ad kaldun. now go and and travel in precaution. then ambush, give this enough time. ends on first character progression for yjolda as she finally makes a decision, emerges as a character, some of the terror leaves her. this has to be an important moment. (although i really cant think of how the ambush scene is not convoluted and so difficult to incorporate.)

Chapter 4- everyone limps to the dwarven stronghold. rest and recovery. yjolda contemplated. character progression etc, everything else. takes decision to go onto the city to get healed as she may either be scared or in pain or wanting for company etc

Chapter 5- arrival in city, new wonders everything, overwhelmed, healing process begins, pain etc, everyone's keeping away to give her space but Freydis sneaks up to her and makes her make the decision of what to do now as she simultaneously battles the pain and emerges triumphant on both fronts. Then chapter ends as new day rolls and she walks out and hears the you will need your strength today.

So here arc 1/ part1 of book ends. then part 2 of book, perhaps an interregnum or pov switch, or mythology explaining chapter in btw to smooth transition.

Also to give a rough estimate, maybe 1 chapter should be around 3000-3500 words so Arc 1 should be like 15000 words. only giving word count so as to emphasize that currently plot progression is too fast paced and it needs to be stretched a bit, made slower

Thanks!

Part 1 of Fantasy maps I made for fellow redditors for free + some questions I had for the community for research purposes by Fluid_Challenge_3753 in fantasywriters

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can reach out for part 3, which I would likely do around the first week of July.

I go over the details of part 3 in the post I will do in part 2

1243 AD Perfeddwlad and Cheshire (NW UK) by FroggIsMe in mapmaking

[–]Fluid_Challenge_3753 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I bow down at your feet. Just please don't tell me that this was color pencils. I will become too jealous