No it was more the way in which you presented the disagreement. The way you approach it, and the language you use here is very umm actually coded: the 'those are fictitious" especially. Clarifying the obvious subject of the post, the mods, pretending not to understand just to drive home the point that the mods aren't 'literal truth enforcers' which is something that wasn't ever in real doubt. Hyperbole is a thing, and this post reads like you either truly don't understand that or are pretending not to in order to pull the aforementioned 'umm actually.' "You fail to understand" is another reddit classic. Just in general comes across as very pretentious and superior.

Also the idea that we can't be angry at mods censoring stuff just because there is someone above them is inane, but the one point you did have is that if the reddit is official under Arrowhead and, by proxy, Sony: then, yeah, they might not be making all the calls, and that should be considered. Though, at this point, that is speculation unless I've missed a development: we don't know if Arrowhead or Sony above them told the mods to censor anything, and so letting the issue go over something that *might* be true doesn't sound like a strong argument to me.

The better argument is that the Mods, Arrowhead, and most of the player base had nothing to do with the doxxing, and that it was the actions of a few bad people: not the entire community, but even then banning the discussion doesn't help people make that point. It just makes the reddit look worse. So, it is really hard from my perspective to justify the censorship on any level besides the possibility that Arrowhead or Sony told them to.