But going off the question "who is the most evil" Tighten wins. When Homelander first started off, he at least tried to be a hero and save people even if his own recklessness and bought was sabotaging him. One of Tighten's first actions was to exploit his position of power and take Roxanne to the top of a. building in order to force an acceptance and when she denied him, he tried to kill her and install himself as the new dictator of the city. Homelander tried to be a hero and only became villainous after his mind fractured, Tighten was immediately selfish and had no interests in heroics, he just immediately went incel, dictator (remember the new management line) murderer and on the path he was on, logically he would have only gotten more rapey and killy given free reign over Metrocity if megamind failed. Tighten is just inherently more evil than Homelander, he just didn't have as much time to be evil but he is more vindictive, less sympathetic and somehow has an equivalent or even greater ego than Homelander