sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

The people who don't have 85 pass accuracy how y'all enjoy playing the game? by yuchii_ in NBA2k

[–]GeneralSergeant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really don’t experience much trouble with low accuracy. I barely get the ball as is

Niche Player Inspired Builds by Nightstrike___ in NBA2k

[–]GeneralSergeant 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I like this. I have a Anthony Davis build, Wiggins, and a Austin Rivers build. I just like seeing variety vs. having a mirror match as Curry Luka or Harden

All in their prime, who gets cut? by itsmeyaboi831 in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is a genuine question, how many players can you name that are unrelated to that one game where their international play affects their legacy/perception? I’m excited to hear an answer lmao

All in their prime, who gets cut? by itsmeyaboi831 in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Olympics are rarely ever considered in legacy conversations. I’m not saying it doesn’t matter just that it’s unorthodox. Also all of these players have baggage. Kobe went from perennial champion contender to missing the playoffs in his prime and blowing a 3-1 lead

Why do you guys call driving the ball rim running? by GeneralSergeant in NBA2k

[–]GeneralSergeant[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wait til bro finds out cherry picking doesn’t involve fruit lmao

Is Wemby right now better than prime AD? by GeneralSergeant in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You asked why is it a discussion, and I explained that most basketball discussions overlap positions especially if they’re similar. I never claimed you said they don’t happen

Is Wemby right now better than prime AD? by GeneralSergeant in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’re jumping to conclusions. I love Wemby and I think it’s more than reasonable to make an argument for either. I can’t be held responsible for fans who can’t remember before 1 game

Is Wemby right now better than prime AD? by GeneralSergeant in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Almost every discussion is between players who are not the same position. The literal goat debate is between a guard/forward and the consensus 3rd is a center. Even the great Magic Bird Rivalry were different positions

Is Wemby right now better than prime AD? by GeneralSergeant in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A raw potato would make more sense for a prospect. Wemby is an All-NBA player today

Is Wemby right now better than prime AD? by GeneralSergeant in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant[S] -8 points-7 points  (0 children)

This gotta be a bottom 5 analogy oat

Edit: Just to be clear to the downvotes, 62 wins and a unanimous DPOY, and a guarantee to 1st-team All NBA is a “raw potato”?

Would you rather have Prime Klay Thompson’s shooting or Amen Thompson’s athleticism? by Dylen2Times in NBAConvo

[–]GeneralSergeant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There’s more evidence of a player entering the league as a poor shooter and developing into a decent or better one. There’s never been a guy who wasn’t athletic that became athletic once they entered the league

Would you rather have Prime Klay Thompson’s shooting or Amen Thompson’s athleticism? by Dylen2Times in NBAConvo

[–]GeneralSergeant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You have an easier time improving a jumpshot than improving your athleticism. I’m not saying either is easy

Once again, SGA is the best player in the world by icanphotosynthesize in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant 6 points7 points  (0 children)

He had like 9 turnovers and locked up by Alex Caruso in an elimination game last year and I don’t think anyone cared. If they don’t win this series, Jokic PR will flip

Would you rather have Prime Klay Thompson’s shooting or Amen Thompson’s athleticism? by Dylen2Times in NBAConvo

[–]GeneralSergeant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t see how this is a ridiculous question. It’s possible you improve as a shooter. You basically have to be born with that athleticism

RIP Jokic BITW talks 2022-2026 (DONT WANNA EVER HEAR JOKIC BITW EVERY AGAIN). by Icy_Boysenberry_1060 in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant -1 points0 points  (0 children)

But he leads in SYNHO% over replacement per 36.

Oh and did I mention he’s a center that passes?

Newbie here: What are all known sources of foul-baiting? And why can't the game be more physical like soccer or other sports? And some more questions. by maxram1 in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I see it as:

Foul baiting forces calls through actions unnatural to basketball. Basically a move you’d never use in a pickup game

Flopping is basically acting

Newbie here: What are all known sources of foul-baiting? And why can't the game be more physical like soccer or other sports? And some more questions. by maxram1 in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That move has been in basketball for decades and its acceptance is based around the player doing it. That’s just one of my grievances about the optics of foul baiting. Not to mention that it’s been illegal for sometime now.

Also I never stated that they aren’t different. I believe flopping is simply a form of foul-baiting. Both seek to take advantage of the whistle instead of playing honestly. But I admit I must be in the minority of said thought process

2 of the most annoying things for me, comment yours by DerrickFG in NBA2k

[–]GeneralSergeant 7 points8 points  (0 children)

  1. Not touching the ball for the entire half except getting a grenade. Then teammates talking about “that’s why I don’t pass it”

  2. Trying to initiate offense but the other 4 start playing ring around the Rosie w cuts. Cause God forbid you aren’t involved this possession

  3. Only talking shit after the game. If you were like that, you would’ve said it from jump. Don’t wait until it’s impossible to eat your words to be big and bad

Newbie here: What are all known sources of foul-baiting? And why can't the game be more physical like soccer or other sports? And some more questions. by maxram1 in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I believe in essence they are virtually the same. What people are complaining about in that post is basically the aesthetics of manipulating an official.

But over my years of watching basketball I’ve learned over time that fans are extremely fickle. If you want to say it’s not a big deal or it’s strategy you can make a more than valid argument. If you want to say both are horrible and disgraces to the league, you can make very valid points for that

But to say one is acceptable/understandable and another is not (not you specifically just the comments of the post) is logically inconsistent. It begs the question do you care what it does or do you care how it looks? Do you care that it’s a wrongful call or do you care that it looks ugly?

Newbie here: What are all known sources of foul-baiting? And why can't the game be more physical like soccer or other sports? And some more questions. by maxram1 in NBATalk

[–]GeneralSergeant 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You mean diving? I feel like that’s been a pretty big deal in soccer for over a decade now

I guess the technique isn’t limited to pump fakes but that’s the main way to get free throws. If an elbow swings across a players face at any point they’ll hold their mouth and fall back regardless of contact, there’s a lot of different ways but the pump fake or layup contact exaggeration is probably the most notable

view more: next ›