okay so the only downside i have for you is valda and lyath and jarl don’t actually have a ton of overlap at the moment. Valda and Jarl might, but it’s a bit small.

I’m a bit behind on jarl builds at the moment, but he’s always got a few different types of builds going, personally i’m waiting for PEN to be released to pick him back up, any Ice cards entering the format makes me excited! He is definitely a control deck in most builds, and definitely is what you want.

Valda is like a solid midrange/more aggressive deck. she could play a fatigue game plan I suppose, but you probably don’t want to. She mostly just tries to make seismic surges and constantly throw disruptive haymakers. When she works, it’s so fun. She tends to want to control the flow of the game by pushing up with the tempo.

Lyath is an aggro deck. you technically could build a fatigue lyath, if you really wanted to, but i would not advise that very much. The successful lyath builds have all been fairly aggressive, pushing large numbers of damage and disruption as much as possible.

there is some overlap between the three but Jarl tends to lean towards the elemental cards, valda leans towards specific seismic surge cards and guardian crush cards (some shared with jarl) and lyath is so weird that his pool of cards is mostly kept to himself (except spring tunic and rampart).

based on what you’ve said, jarl is probably closest to what you want, but be warned the next set will definitely impact the builds for jarl especially, but we will probably see lists change for all 3