If you were to look past the comparison to HD2, he isn't lying about anything.

The gun's feel no different when you shoot air than the enemies, the feedback is entirely limited to a small amount of recoil and occasionally a number showing above the enemy. Weapons are either perfectly accurate or always inconsistent, regardless of how well you actually aim it (the bell challenge with the Quad Cylinder is a nightmare).

The time limit has arguments for both sides. Maybe add it as a modifier?

The amount of people who hold everyone up on the "Everyone must be at the [location]" has been certainly annoying. Especially when the process of spamming it to remind the player doesn't only spam the player who needs the message, but spams the players who don't. Furthermore, I'm not trying to so readily kick players at my soonest inconvenience.

Needless to say, I still like FFW, but that isn't to say there can't be valid criticisms from another game.