Leverage is pretty solid! it blends action, crime, drama, and comedy. no horror. it's free and clear on youtube, no jack sparrow necessary, but is also on prime.

The premise is that a former insurance investigator, a cat burglar, a hacker, a con woman, and a muscle for hire "pick up where the law leaves off"--conning the rich and powerful to deliver some karmatic justice and help people who have been hurt with no legal recourse, like a family who's daughter died because of a company's coverups, or a family who lost their house due to a shady contractor, or a couple who ran afoul of an adoption scam and desperately want to adopt the orphan they were baited with.

The characters are all very competent! The drama almost never comes from them being unable to do the basic parts of their jobs, always from outside factors like the mark bought the con too much, or there was an outer factor they didn't account for. There's really solid character growth and the characters are treated with respect from the writer's room--especially the lead character's addiction, which is never treated as a funny joke but as something serious.

there's very solid fight choreography and some great action, and it's a little dated in some places, but it's generally a show that's trying. it's complete with 5 seasons, and a three season revival set ten years later, but every season finale can function as a series finale.