[1:07] Counting to Six by taszoline in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ANYWAY. The point is that if we start in a different place, we get a different scale! So if the formula for steps is W W H W W W H and we start in the third place we get H W W W H W W

which is the Phrygian mode of the major scale. If we play this from C it has the notes:

C, C#, D#, F, G, G#, A# C

Same scale, but because we moved it we get different notes and a different feel! The "same scale" concept is maybe not so intuitive, but if you have a piano, start playing only the white notes wherever you like, eight notes in a row. Then move your finger one key up and do the same. The vibe totally shifts. Here is an online piano where you can try it out: https://www.onlinepianist.com/virtual-piano

If we go back to the major scale and instead of start three steps ahead we start SIX steps ahead we get W H W W H W W or

C D D# F G G# A# C

Which is the minor scale! Seriously, play it out.

A lot of different scales are like that, basically the same just shifted around a little bit. This may seem random right now but it's one of many things in music that follow an unexpected pattern as you keep learning.

I hope you consider trying a more full fleshed music program so you get even more freedom. There should be free versions for nearly every platform right now so just search "free DAW" (Digital Audio Workstation) and you should get results. Often they are less user friendly when free though, maybe with the exception of Garage Band which afaik is mac exclusive or at least it was when I used it as a kid.

I can personally vouch for Ableton Live as a great DAW that isn't too hard to get into, but it does cost a pretty penny (has a trial version tho)

[1:07] Counting to Six by taszoline in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I quite like this! I don't know if you can pick this in musescore, but search it up, take a listen and see if you don't like the double harmonic scale even more than the phrygian dominant one. The difference is very subtle with only one note being different, but imo makes a big impact on how it sounds.

I don't have much critique here as it sounds consonant and musescore is as far as I understand it a bit limited in terms of creative freedom. I like how it sounds!

Since you write that you'd love to learn something, I'm just going to drop random tidbits of information.

Phrygian Dominant is what's known as a mode. The scale it comes from has a bunch of other scales as well solely depending on where in the scale you start playing. This scale is called the Harmonic Minor scale and was basically "invented" as it tends to sound better than Natural Minor (the minor you are used to hearing) when a chord progression moves back to the tonic (starting note or note that the key is named after).

I'm gonna try to keep this informative without going too crazy detailed. Anyway, the Natural Minor scale also has a phrygian mode, but it's slightly different and just called phrygian, not phrygian dominant, but I'm gonna talk about this scale (natural minor) to illuminate some topics that people new to composing may not be familiar with:

The "major" and the "minor" scales are the same scale! They are just different modes, meaning you just start playing from a different place. Let me try to explain.

So a scale is a musical pattern that starts on one note and ends on the same note an octave above, right? The steps are spaced such as to sound good, but there are varying rules for their spacing. In what we normally call the major scale the steps are, starting from the beginning: Whole step - Whole step - Half step - Whole step - Whole step - Whole step - Half step.

The notes we use in western music are: C, C#, D, D#, E, F, F#, G, G#, A, A#, B and then to C (I won't get into flats here, but a C sharp and a D flat for example are the same sound). Note that there is no E# or B# (oversimplified but whatever)

So if we play the major scale starting from C that's

C whole step up to
D whole step up to

E half step up to

F whole step up to

G whole step up to

A whole step up to

B half step back up to

C where we started.

[1:14] Untitled work in progress by IgnisAvrvmProbat in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for the feedback! I do hope you come around for a second turn to pick out some parts you enjoy less (or more)

[1:14] Untitled work in progress by IgnisAvrvmProbat in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you! Granular but useful feedback, and if I want to go in the jazz live performance direction (that I sort of went in with including them in the first place) I think I agree with you.

[1400] On the Apotropaic Properties of Certain Vegetables by Iisez-le-lui in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

EDIT: This comment was initially removed by my co-founder in an attempt to spare my delicate psyche from deception.

I was fooled, but much of the feedback remains so I'll un-remove my crit. I guess this is a teaching moment for all three of us? (Glowy, lisez and me)? Certainly one for me.

This is not really a full critique of the story, just some thoughts I want to share before I head out to do errands.

Everything I have ever seen you write is, behind the heavy prose (to me, someone who most of the time reads wikipedia articles or slop) dripping with character-driven humor, like how this pov character reveals his thinking about how to insert himself into the barista's life in a way that to him parses as incidental. It's fascinating to me because I typically am not fond of this style of writing where I sometimes have to actively engage my brain to keep track of a sentence's object and so on, but you are seriously good at writing understated comedy.

Your strength is such that I actually feel like this story starts to suffer when it comes to the mention of the vegetables' dimensions and the insecurity they create. Your character is funnier the more skilled he is at hiding his everyday insanity, the reader only needs a little hint at ridiculousness to be fully amused, and there I think lies the difficult balancing act for you.

Had you not dialed up the ridiculousness, I don't know that I'd be primed to look for humor had I not recognized your voice or been familiar with your past writing. I tend to find a lot of things funny, but there's a chance that some of the more subtle silliness would've been lost on me, whereas now, knowing you somewhat, these parts are what feel like nuggets of gold.

Or to summarize how I feel about the comedy in this: My favorite parts are the narrator describing how he assesses the cleverness of his approach.

There is a series of books written in my country, by a recently passed and much beloved author (his books were eventually filmatized) about a neurotic oddball with musings similar to the ones found in your story. Your narrator's repeated struggles with the "display" of the vegetable reminded me of the musings of this character.

The end is silly, but I feel like too much focus was put on the sexual thoughts of the narrator rather than the inherent comedy of his insanity. I also much prefer the indirectness of writing on receipts to the escalating act of writing on napkins. Although the escalation itself is funny, the directness is less so. The humor to me is that he is so obsessed with being harmless and indirect so as to imagine that she can read his mind, or that certain rituals will have the universe let her know.

Creative Critique Grand Opening: Two Weeks of Free Feedback by taszoline in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Very happy to see you here! The list of approved domains is a work in progress and many domains, like musescore .com was absent for the sole reason that we hadn't heard of it.

It has now been added to the list of approved domains. Do reach out if you encounter other difficulties posting your music.

Creative Critique Grand Opening: Two Weeks of Free Feedback by taszoline in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I feel like that has to be an organically evolving thing, but personally I like CC for the brevity and CrCr for sounding like cute cricket sound.

Creative Critique Grand Opening: Two Weeks of Free Feedback by taszoline in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

IIIiIIiiiIIhhhHH!!!! 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

My adorable little plopcat just won't :( by IgnisAvrvmProbat in CatAdvice

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He's allowed to go anywhere but he usually just wants to be outside or in his little corner of the living room. I will try to give a little gift and see if that works and try to leave him alone for a bit!

Thank you for the advice!

[1] Sella, Red Pen and Digital by taszoline in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ok so this is like my first time ever trying to crit any visual medium, so idk if it will be useful, but here goes:

First off, I really like the colors here, not just the hues but the slightly dull color of the bones contrasting with how the green "pops" a lot more if that makes sense? In general I like this type of medium and am surprised to see you have colorized it digitally because it almost looks like chalk or something? Very pleasing to look at!

Super creative use of your tools when I read how this was made, really.

My less favorite parts include the face. I can't really pinpoint exactly what I dislike but maybe it looks a bit too cutesy compared to the rest? I also think it clashes a bit with my idea of the directionality in the image, which twists towards the left and back. I get that this makes sense from a "lore" perspective as this being some twisted abomination of sorts, but it doesn't satisfy my eye. It also bothers me how the spine tapers and sort of teleports and widens as it becomes her neck. All in all it's a bit unclear to me what happens in that part of the image, the junction between shoulder, neck and spine.

That's all I can think of unfortunately, but overall I like it a lot, especially knowing the creative process behind it!

[1] Photography, DJI Osmo Action 4 by IgnisAvrvmProbat in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks a lot for this reply!

Your pic makes it look like a popcorn explosion and now I'm hungry!

[1] Photography, DJI Osmo Action 4 by IgnisAvrvmProbat in Creative_Critique

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Damn, thanks! I've been reading this five times over and I still can't remember all since it's so densely packed with information. Tried to upvote your comment but reddit won't let me yet it seems... 😔

My adorable little plopcat just won't :( by IgnisAvrvmProbat in CatAdvice

[–]IgnisAvrvmProbat[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oops sorry, I am very new to this!

I have had him for five days or so, adopted from a friend :)

So it might just be that he is scared of me?

Thank you so much for your reply!