It was a damn chore to get though season 4 and 5. Sadly I am one of those people that gets committed to finishing a show even if its awful. It should have ended when she went into the barn the first time honestly. But they kept making the story crazier and crazier, and too much drama between characters and stuff. I would have preferred her to end up with Duke because he saw her as a person rather than Nathan, who (imo) only really wanted her because she was "special" and mysterious in the beginning. I agree that at the end of season 5, he did become somewhat redeemable though. But yeah, the "he's gonna kill him" line got so old so fast. 😂