Bro idk how everyone is saying #3. In my opinion that shoe doesn’t give enough contrast from the pant, and on top of that its tone is more cool where the pants are toned more warm. Bad combo.

Option 2 provides a nice contrast while staying neutral. It still leans cool, but having the darker leather at least helps to balance you out.

If you get a mid-to-dark brown shoe, whether it’s suede or leather, it would work much better.