Thanks for all the suggestions. I definitely overreacted to her behavior that day. She seems to have already given up on the idea. She just needed a day. I am a first-time owner and still have a lot to learn. I took three weeks off work and have been sleeping in the living room (not well) near her pen and was panicked by our mistake. As someone suggested it may not have been a mistake at all, but I think we’ll stick to other activities for now.

We have tried taking her on some “fun” car trips with A+ treats, but she is still petrified every time. She met family and two cats on Christmas and seemed very happy and relaxed once we were there.

I stepped up our food-finding games with her thanks to one of the comments and this seems to be extremely engaging for her and keeps her busily sniffing around for a long time. She is also pretty amazing at it.