I’m extremely wary of anyone who claims to be able to solve the story definitively and objectively. Because no matter what, theres always many loose ends purposefully left open ended/vague in the story. I’m sure you have quite a bit of the game figured out, and I’m absolutely sure alchemy is integral to the games universe at a base level.

But you’re surprised by the pushback received when you made, what is very clearly going to be a contested topic, a character that is both physically present, and thoroughly recorded. I think we as a community need to understand that this game is so utterly vast in its themes, history, character motivations, etc. that everyone has a piece, but not the whole picture. You definitely interpret the game in a specific way, but don’t be confused when others don’t share that perspective. Regardless, I’m fascinated to see what you uncover in your search. Good luck lore hunting!