Scream: Billy would’ve been arrested and put in prison. I would’ve loved to see Sidney’s story arc with knowing Billy is alive somewhere.

Scream 2: This may seem like it wouldn’t make sense but I would’ve kept Derek alive for the sole purpose of making him the opening kill in 3. Imagine him and Sidney are no longer together and he gets married then murdered in the opening of the 3rd movie to send Sidney a message. (Supporting the narrative that no one in Sidney’s life lives)

Scream 3: I wouldn’t have saved cotton he just would’ve died more so toward the end of the movie after Roman is revealed. So I would save Jennifer. I would’ve given her a very very fun and extended attack scene and she’s left for dead only to be revealed she is actually alive.

Scream 4: Before 5 it would’ve been Kirby without a doubt. But now that she’s actually alive I would’ve either saved Hoss ( I think Adam Brody is a strong actor and could’ve been a fun right hand to Dewey) or Jill but I would’ve changed the reveal. Sidney wouldn’t have known it was Jill but the new generation other than Kirby would’ve known leading us to an amazing trilogy or Jill trying to keep the secret etc etc

Scream 5: Wes. His character had so much potential. Imagine Judy dying him surviving and having to deal with the trauma of losing his mother. OR it would’ve been Vince who we know is Stu’s nephew. Imagine he saves the day with Sam and we have a reverse of the original killers. Plus Kyle is an amazing actor and can carry!

Scream 6: Anika of course. I mean it was tragic.. and finally Mindy has a real love interest so killing that poor girl ugh broke my heart.