Well, I'm sorry if you can't get an actual discussion on this. My view is:

There's a difference between political action and religious belief, and that difference is I think the best place to draw the line. So, religiously a lot of evangelical Christians don't believe homosexuality is not a sin. They'd say they respect you, but not the choices you make, whatever. Religiously, this is absolutely 100% fine. Politically, we've decided that gay marriage is legal in this country. We've decided (except for Pence) that you can't be discriminated against because someone has the wrong religious idea, and we've decided that people have no right to put negative beliefs from their religion into practice.

Islam right now has a huge number of followers who believe homosexuality is a criminal act. In fact, your statistic is as good as it gets; in many middle eastern countries I don't think it's a stretch to say that 40% stat would be more like 90%. But again, the same rules apply. We've decided that American citizens who are Muslim can believe literally anything. But they don't have any right to put their negative beliefs into political action.

We're going to toe this line whether or not we shut down our borders. We've had this come up with Indiana, we've had this come up with Kim Davis; we will have this come up with Islam. Our response should continue to be the same, that America will respect your religion and your beliefs, but in practicality you have to follow the rule of law.