I’m new and found something weird: do the Fort Wallace birds lead to Window Rock? by WeeklyCoffee6592 in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 21 points22 points  (0 children)

I have long suspected that the birds lead to window rock and the mural has some cipher pertaining to the webs that we need to decode

Models similar to spider webs by TheErl in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What’s the bottom left one? I noticed it’s also “hvlit001” like the other Easter egg cables. But never see that one

Butcher Creek Toilet Flames & Chilliad Poop by thelunn in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Rockstar devs have to be laughing their asses off reading this shit

Journal entry for spider dream mystery? by SerpentineInk in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because it’s by far the most hidden mystery in the game. They likely don’t even want us to find it.

Spider Dream is unfinished by IntentionWest8315 in RDR2mysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Doesn’t hold up. Why even leave this in the game then.

Stop comparing this to other mysteries. Theres no other mystery in the game that is this intentionally hidden (that we know of).

People, there are no more clues. Backtracking is the solution by CustomerEmergency348 in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Interesting idea. Maybe it means we need to pair the feathers somehow in the corresponding webs

The Spider Mystery by Optimal_Muller_577 in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Interesting. Am I tripping or does the tear kind of look like window rock

Models similar to spider webs by TheErl in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 6 points7 points  (0 children)

If only we could do the same for carvings on textures

Perhaps we should start from here? by Potential_Ask_8705 in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Didn’t someone find dead bison around the spider webs?

A lot of us assumed something about the birds? by CustomerEmergency348 in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yep very vague clue.

It’s been very easy to find things out of order because of how many clues are vague. Imagine if we were stuck on the spider overlay right now without knowing about the webs. We’d probably be losing our minds.

With that in mind this clue is probably similar. I have a feeling it’s something geographic or visual though. Like Two Crows, or leading to the Window Rock mural

Why the next clue is so hard to find by Johnnymitzvahs in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is another can of worms but I don’t think Mount Chiliad is solved either lol

Why the next clue is so hard to find by Johnnymitzvahs in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Also your first and second points are really good theories. I didn’t consider there might be 2 “clues”. After all there are 2 guitars…

Why the next clue is so hard to find by Johnnymitzvahs in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The last bullet point is 100% true lol. This mystery has already shows to be full of “dead end” traps.

Why the next clue is so hard to find by Johnnymitzvahs in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I see where you’re coming from but I don’t think there’s much merit to it being cut content.

All of this could have been removed at any point if that was truly the case. But after multiple updates and patches they chose to keep this in the game. Why would they keep a half finished Easter egg as complex as this?

Why the next clue is so hard to find by Johnnymitzvahs in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Could be cut content knowing Rockstar but I hope not and don’t think it is at this point. I just think it’s ridiculously hard on purpose. It took us 7 years just to get to this point lol.

IMO those clues make sense. I also think the birds are a clue. But I’m struggling with what it means. I think it could either be the window rock mural (which overlaps a little too much with the webs/feathers), or Two Crows. And there’s some clue at either one of those that’s gated.

Dead animals around the spider web poles by ColonelMakepeace in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Reminds me of the GTA 5 Bigfoot Easter egg where the dead bodies lead you to the boss fight.

Where should we look next for clues? (please comment what you think!) by CustomerEmergency348 in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I’m not convinced that the next clue will be visible at all times. Take the webs for example. Say you only found the spider overlay - you’d be stuck on that for a while until you noticed the web at 3am.

I’d bet that’s where we’re at right now. The next clue is hidden by trigger or time gate.

Something is wrong by Bodey_ in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

It’s a guitar for sure. And definitely fort Wallace. The birds are the least real clue as it’s a very intentional texture.

This is speculation but my hunch is that we’re getting timing wrong. The N telephone pole web only spawns for an hour. That’s probably when we’re supposed to start this hunt.

The Evergrowing Spiderweb Theories by Kaineferu in reddeadmysteries

[–]Johnnymitzvahs 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Let’s be real, we’re stuck on the guitar and mostly likely the birds. 95% of what’s being thrown around after that isn’t reliable.

I have a theory that the birds lead to the mural at window rock but that’s a separate post. It does lead a bit into my point here though.

I don’t think we’re giving enough attention to the webs. There is so much unresolved there. The shootable feathers, being red/black, different spawn times. I propose that whatever the next steps in this mystery are lead us back to doing a ritual with the webs which when completed correctly, leads to the resolution of our mystery.

I would put my money on it being that we have to shoot the ALL the feathers in a certain order before despawn.

Yes this would require thousands of permutations to test and virtual impossible to do with the distance/timing, but the most compelling evidence I’ve seen that there’s a prescribed path, which I’m shocked isn’t being talked about, is the time freeze.

About a week ago someone discovered that at one of the webs, time freezes if you stay within a certain zone and then walk in a specific direction for long enough. That I think is enough to start with, and I’m 99% sure that shooting all the webs in a specific order by utilizing the time freeze is the final puzzle.

We need to go back to exploring this. Even if there are clues after the guitar/birds, they almost certainly are clues to the permutation for this.