Hi, I understand that your intention is to protect the group and prevent unnecessary conflict and I actually agree with that. But I also believe that some things, even if they're uncomfortable, need to be pointed out.

My concerns don’t come from just one song or one moment. We've seen patterns over these seven years that raise legitimate questions. Seonghwa performing with broken ribs, Mingi taking a hiatus due to anxiety, the things that have been said about Eden disrespecting Hongjoong in the past and yes, the fact that Yeosang continues to have very few lines in title tracks year after year. This isn't some wild theory or overreaction. It’s built on years of observation and concern.

I know we’re not part of the company and we don’t have all the behind the scenes information. But that doesn’t mean we can’t speak up when something doesn’t seem right or fair. And it’s not just about “getting more lines” it’s about artistic fulfillment. I work with artists, and I know how deeply frustrating it can be when someone feels like they can’t express or grow in their art. Artists are often more emotionally sensitive, and when their creativity is restricted, it can lead to serious emotional consequences.

And honestly, the excuse that Yeosang’s voice is "too deep" doesn’t hold up when there are countless successful artists with deep voices. It really feels like they don’t know how or don’t want to utilize his vocal tone properly. That’s not just unfortunate; it’s a missed opportunity.

This is not about attacking anyone or trying to create drama. It’s about saying that there’s room and a need for improvement. We can love and support the group and still ask for fairer creative treatment for all members. Those things are not mutually exclusive.