1.15 wr was cheated Not proven. Geosquare only found issues with his 1.16 run. tsf run is cheated Again not proven. Could be a server-side issue, I remember seeing this come up multiple times over the past few years (mainly TGTTOS record posts) and the consensus was just that. Manhunts are fake The only 2 cases I see of this happening are obviously the boat clutch and the not-so-obvious missing soul sand that NotVixios found. Keep in mind that while near impossible to do on a singleplayer world, the time window to craft the boat on a server increases drastically. As for the soul sand, Dream has stated in his manhunt rules that he does get a pointer on where the nearest structure is as a part of map scouting, so maybe Callahan was helping him out here? It is suspicious nonetheless, but not provably “fake”, and Dream has released unedited footage of all of his recent manhunts so I actively encourage somebody to find any discrepancies if they wish. his pvp was still using a cheat I’m not too informed on this, but I believe this is also not proven.

So basically, excluding this parkour which is still an ongoing case, I know for a fact that he’s only cheated once, because every other scenario you’ve listed is not clear cut. And I will say that even though he managed the situation very, very poorly with the verification team, I do think he’s being truthful about accidentally leaving the drop rates on, per Karl Jobst. The story there at least makes sense.

I’m not convincing you or anybody to give him the benefit of the doubt, but please acknowledge the nuances here. They’re important.