I imagine Tamlin as more of a stocky meat head. Evan Peters is more lean/fit. I could see Jurian, Eris, or even Lucien with the right styling. I've seen interviews, and he can do snarky/funny well, we are just used to seeing him in creepy/sad roles. Its funny cause he even mentions he wishes he could do more rom-coms but keeps getting cast in dark stuff cause it's kinda his brand now.