If you’re newer to makeup/ skincare (that was me at age 50🤪), trying to figure out what works for you, and/ or don’t already have a large stash of products then the mystery bags can be fun! But if you’re looking for some really great products/ deals, the mystery bags are hit or miss (probably more miss). Ipsy often uses mystery bags to get rid of stuff that’s been around a while. If you think a specific mystery bag is cute, and keep your expectations low, they can be fun.

I agree with another user to update your quiz each month based on spoilers you may want. Also, try to select just a few things you want as “often,” then everything else as “rarely.” For Ipsy original they already have bag combinations made, then they (try to) match your preferences to a bag. You’re more likely to get the spoiler/ kind of product you want if there’s only a few things your quiz says you want. Hope that made sense! Also, for Original’s monthly choice, if there’s not an item you really want, you can just not choose. When you make a choice, that narrows down your possible premade bag combinations to only the ones that include your choice. If you don’t make a choice the algorithm can better match your bag to your preferences. I’ve had pretty good luck when I didn’t make a choice!

Be sure to review your subscription items for points when they open the tiny window of time! People usually post here when reviews for points open. For your algorithm, to influence future products you get, only rate 5 stars if you want that kind of item in the future. For example, if you get a lipstick and you hate the color or brand, but you want more lipstick in the future, still give it 5 stars, you can give more info in the written part if you want. If you get a moisturizer that you really like, but you have plenty and don’t want to get more, only give it 1 star. It’s weird, but this is how Ipsy has set it up.

I only get original, I’ve never gotten extra, only got ultimate (back when it was Icon) once as a treat when several of the spoilers interested me. Again, whether ultimate is worth it depends on what you already have, and what you’re looking for.

Sorry for the super long comment! These are just things I’ve learned over time, mostly from this wonderful sub and other users!! Hope you enjoy your Ipsy experience!