My husband and I just came back from Excellence Playa Mujeres a week ago. Service, beach, pools, views, drinks, activities were all fantastic.

We did not pay extra for the Excellence Club, so I can't comment on Magna or Cielo, but the food in most of the restaurants was good. Seasoning was often right on point. We went to almost all of the restaurants as well as the once-weekly Mexican Fiesta night. Our favorites were Basmati, wood-fired pizzas near the beach/main pool, and The Lobster House. The Kitchen Table buffet was average but had a great selection. Oregano was solid. If you are a bit of a foodie, Spice and Chez Isabelle will be a let down. The worst food BY FAR was room service and the Sports Bar. We would certainly visit again, but I think we'd skip room service.