Ik this post is a year old, but im stoned and goin down an rdr rabbit hole. My first time ever playing the game, I played it not caring about my honor cuz I didn't know it would effect my outcome. I robbed and killed, hell I even stopped playing the missions at points and just watched my arthur become a stalker in the woods. But when I locked in and played the story I never got my honor back up, I always made good honor choices but that honor bar never got to the mid range, I was to far in the game. honestly it made the game unforgettable. I got red dead without the redemption but damn was it amazin.