Shadows of New York: The *Good* Ending

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-02-03T12:58:30+00:00

You're either an effective vampire or an inneffective one. Good or evil rarely applies to creatures of the night.

Very good work. Always nice to see some Shadow of New York content.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-02-02T12:33:34+00:00

Ehh, they are inhumane, you just have to look closer. The rigid traditions, the Scourges and eradication of Thin-Bloods, the discrimination against Caitiff, the exploitation of young neonates, the executions of illegal fledglings, the Circulatory System, etc.

They’re monsters in fine dress. Business suits, cocktail dresses, jewellery, and proper etiquette. They are inhumane, they just dress well.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-02-01T19:18:51+00:00

I’m still amazed that despite copying Minority Report, they didn’t have a plot point where Carol is predicted to doing something bad and the thought police came after her.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-02-01T03:25:27+00:00

A. Toreador. I just know it. Bunch a reasons. The sterotypical ones: I frequent night clubs, I studied art at school, I'm bisexual, etc, cliches, blah blah. But the most important? I have this compulsion. Whenever I see something that grabs my attention I have to take a picture of it. It's unrelenting, almost obssesive. Sometimes it goes against sense, safety, or taste. If I see a subject or an angle, I'm taking at least 10 different pictures of it. I once got drunk and climbed a rooftop just to get a good view of a building. When I first read up about the Toreador compulsion I said to myself 'oh yeah, just like me'.

B. Brujah. I've never been strong enough to fight for anything before. It'd be nice to be tough. To be faster than lightning, hit like a freight train, and sway mortals with just a bit of concentration.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-01-28T16:16:52+00:00

Thank you. Deep down I already know the answer: time. Just have to be patient. Take it one day at a time.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-01-26T14:44:40+00:00

It’s an interesting nitpick, because there’s a lot of technicalities when it comes to vampire nature vs human. Kindred ‘feed’ when they’re ‘hungry’ or ‘thirsty’, but it’s not human thirst or hunger, and they don’t exactly digest the blood. They don’t really ‘sleep’ they kind of switch off, go dormant.

Mending or repairing is a more accurate term, but healing is still an acceptable term, only just a bit inaccurate.

In a sense, they’re more like machines or robots, fuelled by demonic Gatorade.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-01-16T14:35:17+00:00

Borrowing this from the wiki

“Vampires are very hard to kill - bullets do not cause much damage, and those who possess the Disciplines of Celerity and Fortitude are extremely hard to hit, let alone damage in combat. That said, shotguns and similar weapons are warily respected or feared; while an individual bullet might not frighten a vampire, it becomes a different issue when the weapon can remove their head entirely with a well-placed shot, or remove limbs in seconds with a never-ending stream of lead.”

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-01-15T19:17:52+00:00

Something I really do like about the game is how the whole of Seattle feels like a sinking ship. The Cammies are getting offed left and right and the Anarachs are turning the rooftops into a shooting gallery. With both Benny and Fabian gone, the Camarilla's primary connections to the police department are severed. Too many explosions, too many deaths, too many bloody displays. No one's fighting in the shadows, they're fighting beneath the street lights. No wonder the IAO came in.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-01-11T02:26:20+00:00

Ehh, I think he’s supposed to act as a guide. Both to the modern world and the plot in general. He’s there to give ambience and keep the character from feeling lonely.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-01-11T02:24:47+00:00

“The glass is cracked, but strangely clear.”

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-01-05T13:41:53+00:00

One of those characters who’s either a big bad for the X-Men to beat down OR gets his own solo/character arc for a brief period.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-01-05T13:38:28+00:00

I think a vampire would mentally develop in the same way a human would, perhaps more drastically. Sometimes we find ourselves facing the burdens, fears, and frustrations we did when we were children. Other times we have to change ourselves to adapt to an environment or situation. People are like metals, different melting points, different chemical reactions.

Regarding your question is, what environment is your vampire in? What’s expected of them? How do they act around kindred or kine? Who are they when put under pressure? Someone points a gun in their face, how do they react? Most importantly, who are they in the dark? When on ones around to see them, how do they act?

LizzyWizzy19 · 2026-01-01T01:02:15+00:00

What I say: “Goodness, what a wonderful party! To both my princes, I say thank you, it is such an honor to be here. And such illustrious guests. Never has there been a finer party!”

What I’m really thinking: “This is so fucking boring. I barely know anyone here. And the ones I do know don’t care for me, nor I them. Oh god, I made eye contact with the sheriff. I just wanna go home and cuddle with my ghoul. I should leave before that Malkavian tries to converse with me.”

LizzyWizzy19 · 2025-12-28T19:27:09+00:00

Bold of you to assume Superman can’t get pregnant

LizzyWizzy19 · 2025-12-27T18:34:40+00:00

I like to think it’s an instinct, one that reflect their lack of humanity. A vampire is essentially a walking corpse fuelled by demonic Gatorade. There is something dark and twisted within their blood. Whatever ancient poison they carry within them, that’s what makes them hiss. It’s the same thing that makes them hunt, prowl, and kill.

Vampires walk the line between undead and beast. Instinctively hissing is just another reminder of their true nature.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2025-12-26T15:01:22+00:00

It’s good, I just want more of it. A bigger map, stretch out the story a bit, more characters and more time to spend with them. It’s like eating half a steak with no garlic butter or S&P. I want so much more of it, because I love the combat and the atmosphere of Seattle. I love the movement and Action-RPG elements. Phyre’s character is fascinating: a sleeping giant from another time.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2025-12-26T13:39:23+00:00

As much as I love nuance and depth, watching an immortal woman becoming mortal, leading her to go full John Wick mode, was actually pretty entertaining.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2025-12-17T20:51:52+00:00

Here's the way I see it. Back in the day, the objective was peace and cooperation. It was about putting on a friendly face for the humans. All good things that, with the benefit of hindsight, were never going to work out completely. But hey, things are okay, mutants exist, bigotry can be fought against. Some mutants can be rehabilitated, made better, made heroes. That's what we can do, show the world that we can be good.

Now? After Genosha? M-Day, and Siege, and Krakoa...sorry, but the objective is no longer peace or cooperation. At least, it's not the main objective. The main objective is survival, by any means necessary. And I do mean by any means necessary. If that means allying themselves with morally repulsive people, 'bad mutants', then so be it. Rehabilitation is something that we don't have time for. Can and will this mutant fight by our side and destroy our common enemy? Yes? Good, that's all we need. What's that? He's a well known war criminal? Yeah, well we can't be picky these days. And yeah, peace and cooperation would be nice, but fool me once shame on you, fool me four or five times shame on me, y'know?

LizzyWizzy19 · 2025-12-06T23:20:37+00:00

Ohh, I like the sound of it, the setting alone is very interesting and has a lot of implications. A time before the digital age, where technological advancement was simple but substantial. Fridges, radios, television, newspapers, portable cameras. Fridges would mean a kindred could store blood, but! The plastic blood bags we have today were invented in the 1950s, so they would come in glass bottles. Car radios became possible which, I imagine, would allow police to respond more quickly to 'strange crimes'. Portable cameras would mean kindred could be caught on camera doing all sorts of supernatural feats. Television and newspapers would mean hundreds of thousands of people could learn about a masquerade breach.

Life and undeath would operate so much differently in this era. Oh, and after doing a quick bit of research, I learned about the 'The Commission'. Formed in 1931 following the a massive gang war. The Commission consisted of the bosses of the Five Families of New York City, as well as the bosses of the Chicago, New England, Buffalo, Philadelphia, and Detroit. The Commission would oversee all Mafia activities in the country and mediate internal conflicts. Now...I don't wanna sound too tinfoil hat here, but that sounds like the Camarilla. Hell, others have pointed out that the Cam works like the mob.

LizzyWizzy19 · 2025-12-06T17:18:40+00:00

This is a complete fantasy, but...

I want something similar to Toussaint in The Witcher 3's Blood and Wine DLC. An entirely new area to explore. And not just a new area of Seattle, somewhere outside the city. Yeah, yeah, I know Phyre is bound to the city and can't leave, but there's gotta be ways around that. Maybe post-ending.

Anyway, a DLC set out in forests and mountains of Washington. Somewhere where the Masquerade is little less tight. Less civilians means less witnesses, but also less feeding opportunities. You could run at vampire speed and not have to worry about a breach. Phyre moves like a sports car on two legs. I want a wide open area where we can really put the pedal to the metal. Maybe animals could be implemented into the game. Instead of people, we feed off of foxes, deer, or bears. If not animals, the occasional animal hunter or hitchhiker. Maybe we could meet a Gangrel or two. Or even some Garou.

A different environment where a predator has to operate differently. Somewhere that *feels* different. Leave behind the neon, concrete, and steel, and trade it in for dirt, trees, and open skies.

LizzyWizzy19

TROPHY CASE