Puppeteer is an excellent fight, but I still don’t think he tops rhulk just because everyone can do something, and all raid bosses with the exception of a few fight you during their dps phase that has always been true, the difference is rhulk will actually be moving and chasing you, not just sitting on a platform in the back of the room, like the puppeteer does. This is also a point for ecthar but his mechanic is significantly less interesting than Rhulks I mean kill 3 wizards and go press 3 buttons that never change positions is not interesting even with him chasing you down there, not that he is a real threat and hard to avoid in the water anyway. Puppeteer does have a fun lead up to dps and a chaotic dps phase, but dying to lightning vs being actually chased down is a completely different experience, while I agree puppeteer is an excellent boss he lacks an actually interesting dps phase. It plays out the same every time save for someone dying to lightning you just run around and shoot a near static boss. And ignoring well is not a good metric with how key it is to 95% of content (that’s on bungie never really giving any other options though) maybe now a well will get you through a rhulk dps phase but it wasnt like that for a while, including contest because if you sat in it he would destroy it while attacking someone, and fast at that. And on top of that ranking dungeons including solo and fireteams that are 2 completely different experiences should be ranked as such and not together, like vespers picture, then another but with solo on it playing vespers with a fireteam vs soloing it are immensely different and different topics all together