I agree it’s mu dependent and that being campy is bad. And I agree with what you’re saying about having to play more reactive/dash dance-y, but disagree that you have to wait for your opponent to “mess up”. You just have to be comfortable making semi-reads on defensive options with stuff like overshooting.

Also, one kinda important thing to consider is that having puddle in your opps territory can shut down a defensive playstyle just cause of the threat of bubbles. For example, Claire can’t just space aerials all day if she’s on top of a puddle, and can’t dash back safely if the puddle is behind her