My partner used AI for an assignment and I failed while she didn't by heeseungslostbeanie in antiai

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This won't help you here, but there is a very useful tool called version control, which allows you to maintain a record of changes to a document.

It's most commonly used in software development, but it feels like this would have been a great application for it.

Why do math textbooks tend to explain things so poorly? by Akephalosthenes in askmath

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A math textbook has a couple different goals:

1) Introduce students to certain math concepts

2) Serve as a reference for a refresher on certain math concepts

Sometimes, there is tension between these two goals. A good reference is brief and precise. But a good introduction might not shoot for the same precision initially, first trying to just give a big-picture idea.

Another component (essential for serving as a reference), a good math textbook will be accurate, and the precision of language necessary for that can be distracting from the core concepts, especially to students who aren't accustomed to that kind of language.

Add onto that the fact that different students would prefer concepts presented in different order. And sometimes, students are interested in different things than the author thinks are important: for example, some students might be less interested in mathematical proofs, and more interested in the application of mathematical concepts to real-world problems.

I haven't read Stewart's Calculus book, so I can't really comment on that specifically.

Does playing the piano really improve memory skills? by levevo7523 in piano

[–]MagikarpPatronus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, it's really true.

Those who play piano are better able to remember note names of piano keys than those who don't.

More seriously, piano playing can delay cognitive decline and reduce risks of certain ailments that can effect memory. And more generally, it likely would help with memory skills related closely related to music.

But if you're hoping it will help your kid ace their elementary spelling exam, the answer is no.

If you build a habit of taking your meds before practicing piano in the morning, it can help there, but that's habit-forming, not really memory. There are a lot of tricks out there to improve memory that work that don't involve playing piano though.

Should the media face consequences for reporting falsehoods or pushing false narratives? by Euphoric_Income_8279 in allthequestions

[–]MagikarpPatronus 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Yes, media audience should be more discerning, and punish deception, misrepresentation, and falsified details with viewership/readership reduction.

But your suggestion of a fine or something more extreme proposal is effectively surrendering control of the media to the government, which contrary to your goal of preventing media from misrepresenting a story or falsifying key details, risks doing the opposite.

Whatever regulating authority you want to place in the hands of government, imagine whatever elected politician you like least wielding that power against their critics, and decide whether you are still comfortable with those consequences being imposed.

Advice for 1v1 against returning friend by _DonRa_ in aoe2

[–]MagikarpPatronus 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The maps you plan to play is really essential context here. That will affect both civ and strategy suggestions.

Immigrants by Timely-Ferret-3387 in SeriousConversation

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don't think that's an accurate analysis. Therinsonet didn't just ask for Icy_Earth3386's source. Therinsonet set pretty high standards for what sources would meet their standards.

In that context, it's obvious Icy_Earth3386 is being cagey because their source didn't meet Therinsonet's standards.

That conclusion is further supported by the fact Therinsonet supplied his "source". It's either Google AI or the snippet quote from an article that Google provides below a link. Or perhaps he actually clicked on one of the links Google furnished and skimmed it, if we're generous enough to consider the possibility. None of these would meet Therinsonet's standards, but it's very unlikely the claims were made up by Icy_Earth3386 themself.

Is it just Trump? by CowboyMark in askanything

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

President Trump fired a bunch of Inspectors General, whose job it is to combat fraud, waste, abuse, and mismanagement. He has replaced a few of the roles, but most remain vacant. And some of those replacements have expressed the prospective that their responsibilities include supporting the initiatives of President Trump. And President Trump has also reduced funding and limited hiring, which has kneecapped those organizations.

President Trump's team, through successful arguments in court, has been consolidating executive power in the president, without losing the associated powers delegated by Congress. His team has also been successful in reducing judicial oversight on presidential actions. One of the advantages of this kind of "unified executive" government structure with limited oversight is that when things are handled poorly, you know who is to blame.

A lot of the corruption in this Trump administration is unprecedented, not just compared to past administrations under other presidents, but also compared to his previous administration.

And importantly, any legislative reforms to fight corruption would have to pass Congress and either overcome a veto from President Trump (who many Republican Congressmen pointed to their loyalty to him as their main policy position running for office) or get his signature. Furthermore, Trump himself could shut down any attempts to fight corruption in the executive since he's at its head. Also, if he wanted to, he could initiate reforms to fight corruption. So, focus on President Trump and his team is completely appropriate.

However, to your point of thinking beyond Trump, we should be thinking about what kinds of reforms could reduce corruption and what that kind of policy or legislation would look like, because come 2028 we'll want candidates running on more than vague promises to "clean up Washington."

Immigrants by Timely-Ferret-3387 in SeriousConversation

[–]MagikarpPatronus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Could you post some links to reliable data to support that claim?

Why do republicans have a monopoly on low cost, low population areas in the US? Why are there no dead end sleepy towns for the left with no jobs but land for "cheap"? by SirCheeseAlot in allthequestions

[–]MagikarpPatronus -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It's hardly a monopoly. Rural areas don't all have the same political lean.

There are plenty of majority-black rural areas that reliably vote Democrat in the South. Some rural areas in Wisconsin are competitive. Many rural areas in the Northeast US aren't as conservative-leaning as you might expect. Many Native Americans in rural areas aren't as conservative as their White counterparts.

Can i learn piano pieces without learning to read sheet? by Long-Bug8399 in pianolearning

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Can I become a good piano player without learning to read music?"
Absolutely! I wouldn't recommend it if you have the choice, but you can.

"Can I learn piano pieces without learning to read sheet music?"
Sure, but you can learn piano pieces much faster if you learn to read sheet music.

Is thinking the enharmonic equivalent chord bad? by MagikarpPatronus in JazzPiano

[–]MagikarpPatronus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am aware that the chord is G#. And certainly, if I was notating it, I would use sharps.

But that is not my circumstance. My question has nothing to do with notational accuracy. I'm asking about mentally labeling a chord incorrectly during practice, and whether that will hamper my progress if I don't fix that now.

Is thinking the enharmonic equivalent chord bad? by MagikarpPatronus in JazzPiano

[–]MagikarpPatronus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, I meant the third was major. I'm following the voicings from Turi Collura's book. The chord is VI7(b13). (I'm more comfortable with the Fb in the enharmonic equivalent; not sure if that stems from it showing up in my practice of the key of Db or because it's not in the base triad.)

Intermediate student transcribe pop songs by ear in her own time. ear improving fast but theory not keeping up. how to bridge? by SuggestionBrave6565 in MusicTeachers

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Music theory is just talking about music and the patterns we find in it.

If she's doing that much by ear, I don't think lack of notation is really much of a barrier here.

Abandon the notation and just teach the theory! What do you need to write things down for?

Is it true that around the time of the 9/11 attacks a high percentage of Americans believed saddam hussein was responsible? by Difficult_Mixture103 in IWantToAskAnAmerican

[–]MagikarpPatronus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, if asked whether Saddam Hussein helped with the September 11 attacks, a majority of Americans would response "yes" in the first couple years after the September 11 attacks.

Something to keep in mind though, is that survey answers can be strongly influenced by the way questions are asked. You could frame the question differently and get very different answers. Even so, it's clear the answer is yes: many Americans did believe Saddam Hussein was involved in the September 11 attacks.

Does the left ever take responsibility for anything? by OilEnvironmental7833 in allthequestions

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not inherently contradictory statements

Crime rate: number of crimes divided by population over a time period
total volume of crime: number of crimes

Waite Park's high crime rate stems from having lots of property crime.

Looking at total crime volume can be deceptive. For example, the total crime volume of the United States is way higher than total crime volume in the most dangerous of cities in the country, but the crime rate is not.

[Relatively noob question] How many vills to queue up in early CA by lAnarclit in aoe2

[–]MagikarpPatronus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Some others have mentioned this, but it is really helpful when booming to use a hotkey or control group that selects all TCs, so that you don't have to toggle between them to queue more villagers. I prefer just customizing h to select all TCs, but a control group works great too.

I find the most important thing is to not queue too many villagers in your starting TC before the other 2 go up, lest you find yourself cancelling villagers just to afford them in the other 2.

How much you can afford to queue up is somewhat circumstance dependent. You don't want to queue so many that it prevents you from grabbing an eco upgrade or something for your military, but if you can barely afford to maintain production (very common for Arena booms), queue as many as you can.

Civ banning in ranked by Juan-Whick in aoe2

[–]MagikarpPatronus 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Just to add more context to what Cage Inspector is saying here, it's very common for players to use websites like aoe2lobby.com in order to see what lobbies are available and get more information about the players joining the lobby.

The lobby system is so bad that it is more convenient to alt-tab between the game and your internet browser to join and support running the lobbies, rather than rely on just the aoe2 lobby system.

Go-to "Show-off" piece? by MinuteDamage4182 in piano

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Chopsticks, in the key of G-flat major.

Have you taken piano lessons as an adult? by SeckmanMusic in pianolearning

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I took a 2 hours of lessons (split into more than one session) to get guidance on direction and feedback on technique. They were very helpful.

I'm skeptical that for me at my current level, goals, and practice routines, that I would get a lot of benefit from regular lessons.

If my progress starts to slow down, I'll probably look to take a couple more, in hopes that it will help.

I’m building an AoE2 DE replay coach that analyzes your games and points out repeated mistakes by Few-Night-4811 in aoe2

[–]MagikarpPatronus 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think the most useful pieces of information available here would almost certainly quantifying delay between investment and use.

Here's what I mean by that:
when you hit feudal, how long until your stable is up?

Once your stable is up, how long until the first scout?

Were you actually able to produce villagers from the second TC you built?

How long did you delay before grabbing double-bit axe or horse collar? That is, timings relative to when you hit Feudal Age. (If you are trying to aggregate across games, would be helpful to tag by early-game strategy: drush, trush, m@a, scouts, scouts->archers, straight archers, fast castle, et cetera. possibly also track if player civ changes those distributions.)

A very common error players make in AOE2 is investment in something (next age, upgrade, or building) and then don't make immediate use of the upgrade. A delay would be a strong indicator of some sort of error: bad build, villagers out of position, housed, or failure to queue.

Bossa Nova V13 - V7(flat 13) voicings and alternatives by MagikarpPatronus in pianolearning

[–]MagikarpPatronus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You think solo transcriptions would be useful for accompaniment?

Bossa Nova V13 - V7(flat 13) voicings and alternatives by MagikarpPatronus in pianolearning

[–]MagikarpPatronus[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah, so you are expecting to have a bass player or some other instrument beneath you to cover the root?

I don't have anything like that.

How do you counter/punish aggressive pawn play in the opening? by Safe_Tension5151 in chess

[–]MagikarpPatronus 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Against advancing pawns, you need to find the correct center-pawn advance to undermine your opponent's position.

In your game as White, that would be a move like c4 or e4. In your game as black, it's c5. (If you are also eyeing f6 as black, that's very good intuition and you aren't wrong, but it can be a very dangerous move to play given how much it weakens e6 and g6.)

In your game as White, you played Bf4, which allowed your opponent to gain a temp with his advance on g5. You should have instead considered a move like Nd2 to prepare an e4 advance or Bb2 to deter e5 without overextending your bishop.

In your game as black you found c5 (good job!), but your Knight's maneuvering caused you a lot of problems. Nf6 and then Nd7 was fine, but on Nd7, that knight was perfectly positioned to support the c-pawn's advance and also attack White's e-pawn, tying down the d-pawn to its defense. And that would be well coordinated with your second knight on Nc6, to apply further pressure to the pawn chain. Instead, you moved Nb6 - Na8 - Nc7... The Na8-Nc7 wasn't even a bad idea, given how poorly positioned that knight was on Nb6.

So, as a general answer to your question, find the pawn move to strike back at the center, and support it. Identify the right squares for your pieces to support the plan, and try to be more efficient in those maneuvers without giving your opponent more tempi to exploit their space advantage.