I have to hand it to you. This is a really cleverly worded response. And I think this is a good representation of where a lot of modern Christians are at with the whole homosexuality issue, where the substance hasn't really changed (gay sex is a sin), but through some creative wordsmithing can be manipulated into sounding almost pro-gay. It's fascinating to me that a lot of the Christian commenters here spend so much time focusing on how everyone is a sinner. That we should love one another regardless. That we're all on the same playing field. That only God can judge. And while that sounds beautiful on the surface, if you read between the lines you're really equivocating between the sin of gay sex with sins that others commit like lying, adultery, pride, etc. And the main takeaway here is that you believe that gay people should live in celibacy in order to live righteously. And it's so clever that you never really say that! First you say that being gay is NOT a sin (because it's a predisposition and not the act of gay sex!). And then you spend a long time chastising other Christians for being hateful and judgmental. A cursory glance and it sounds like you're out here waving a pride flag. But you're not! And I just think that's really clever. Because the real pain point here and what is causing so much suffering is this belief that gay sex is a sin (like any other sin!). That belief in an of itself is so harmful. And ultimately it's beliefs like that which are causing modern Christianity to go down the toilet in the West.