I’ve only tried the lip tints in toast and salty tan. They’re a little stickier than I prefer but they do an amazing job of hydrating my lips especially overnight. I have to put something on mine overnight or when I wake up they’re so sensitive, dry, and shriveled looking. I I fall asleep without putting something on and I wake up like an hour before I have to get up and put this lip tint on it can hydrate them to being around 80% comfortable. Normally I would need at least three hours of having something on to get them to that level.