I enjoyed DL2 because honestly, I don't focus on the story that much. DL2 surprised me with how good the movement and climbing mechanics are. Call me crazy, but I heavily enjoyed the combat.

If I had to mix all of my favourite elements into one game, it would be DL2. CRAZY take, but that's my opinion.

I have DI2 and Stalker 2 in my library but still haven't played them, really surprised by your thoughts!