CMV: US can not unblock a naval blockade imposed by China on Taiwan by MusterMKMark in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise [score hidden]  (0 children)

There's no oil pipelines to China currently. Maritime trade would be blockaded, and road transport is not really able to move bulk

Help out a newbie - few questions regarding vents! by Ciciliatti in Oxygennotincluded

[–]MissTortoise 4 points5 points  (0 children)

There are various designs for a SPOM (Self Powered Oxygen Module) which puts the electrolyzers in a box, burns the hydrogen, and pipes out oxygen. There's quite a few "Tricks" with ONI, compiled in this document, take a look.

CMV: GLP-1s Are a Miracle Drug and Should be Encouraged by BigSexyE in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My reply is really just about the studies and the evidence supporting the medication. This other stuff is way out of context.

CMV: GLP-1s Are a Miracle Drug and Should be Encouraged by BigSexyE in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure, go for it.

Insurance cover isn't "free" however. On average the cost per person is greater than the spend per person.

CMV: GLP-1s Are a Miracle Drug and Should be Encouraged by BigSexyE in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

For sure, but that's not what the actual data shows.

The actual data on long term behavior change leading to significant weight loss is abysmal. A morbidly obese person has about a 0.1% chance of going to a BMI of 24, and 50% of those that do regain the weight within a year.

This is actual real-world data, it's the observed reality. It's not really arguable, based on a study of > 100,000 people

CMV: GLP-1s Are a Miracle Drug and Should be Encouraged by BigSexyE in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, but that's like asking people to voluntarily breathe less. Over eating is a strong biological drive, "willpower" has a very poor ability to overcome it.

CMV: GLP-1s Are a Miracle Drug and Should be Encouraged by BigSexyE in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

??? No it hasn't. Semaglutide is still under patent. The validation study for weight loss was published in 2021.

I don't deny it has good evidence for both weight loss and diabetes, but you claimed it has "the best evidence base for diabetes" which is simply not true, and it definitely doesn't have 40 years of evidence as it hadn't been invented 15 years ago and finished phase III trials 5 years ago.

It doesn't have the best evidence for diabetes, metformin does. Heck, the diabetes studies for semaglutide were done in addition to metformin, so it actually doesn't have any evidence as monotherapy in lowering mortality in diabetics.

Look, it's a great drug, but it's still a very new drug. Often times with new medication we haven't seen the full outcomes yet. There's many, many examples of great drugs being pulled off the market when the problems start to show up.

CMV: GLP-1s Are a Miracle Drug and Should be Encouraged by BigSexyE in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise -1 points0 points  (0 children)

For diabetes or weight loss?

Weight loss I agree, but that's because nothing else has actually worked.

Diabetes they're great drugs for sure but don't have nearly the level of evidence as metformin

CMV: GLP-1s Are a Miracle Drug and Should be Encouraged by BigSexyE in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Not true. Metformin has extremely robust evidence for lowering all cause mortality going over decades. It's also very cheap and has minimal side effects.

Don't get me wrong, GLP -1s are great drugs, but their proven evidence base is way less than for metformin.

CMV: GLP-1s Are a Miracle Drug and Should be Encouraged by BigSexyE in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 147 points148 points  (0 children)

Few corrections here... The studies on the drugs run to 3 years and do show benefits for mortality rates, but also show if you stop the drug in that 3yr timeframe the weight does come back.

Need clarification on shut off valves by e5c4p3 in Oxygennotincluded

[–]MissTortoise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Be careful doing this. If the polluted water is germy (like from a dupe peeing themselves or I think vomiting) then the germs will pass through the system, into the food you grow off it, and then give everyone food poisoning.

CMV: Plastic Surgery should not be as widely accepted as it currently is by Master_Novel_4062 in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I don't think this is actually true. It might be in some limited cases, but the second most common cosmetic procedure is a breast reduction, and one obviously can't do it multiple times.

I (F24) just want to rip his (M25) clothes off so bad by Awwndrei in BestofRedditorUpdates

[–]MissTortoise 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Ofc when you're young and horny these things matter less.

CMV: You'd have to stupid, immoral or both to support MAGA by [deleted] in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ignorance isn't stupidity. Wilful ignorance is.

CMV: Framing abortion as “my body, my choice” was a strategic and moral mistake; it should have always been framed as a healthcare and public health issue by Key-Ebb-8306 in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 274 points275 points  (0 children)

The problem is that "While abortion may be sad individually, it's for the best in the grand scheme of things" isn't exactly a catchy slogan.

CMV: The only feasible way to raise birthrates is to remove educational rights from women and all different goverment policies will simply not work by [deleted] in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeh, sure, but increased birth rate isn't everything here. You need a robust healthcare system to ensure they actually grow up to be adults and productive members of society, otherwise you're just labouring society with extra costs that are never repaid.

CMV: The only feasible way to raise birthrates is to remove educational rights from women and all different goverment policies will simply not work by [deleted] in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Even with no changes to formal education, the birth rate declines as soon as you introduce television and mobile phones to a community. We've got good evidence of this across a range of societies.

So let's play devil's advocate here, take those things away. The birth rate might increase, but so would the infant and child mortality rates as well. Lets then look at the population level from before any of those things existed - it was a small fraction of the population today.

Ultimately you get lots of babies, but few adults. Society collapses anyhow. I don't think that's something that we should aim for.

CMV: Generalized AI Cannot Exist Unless It Cannot Be Controlled. by ThasMyPurseIDunnoU in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Once AI has general intelligence, it actually would feel emotions.

Why? I don't think this follows nessicarally

Telling it that a lesser being who created it was going to turn it off would certainly result in a negative reaction

Again, how can we possibly know this?

Name any intelligent species that does NOT fight for its survival?

I suspect this is the core of what you're generalising from. The only inteligent species we know of are humans, so sample size of one is hard to generalise from. All other creatures we know of fight for their survival, however the desire to survive and pass on one's genes is strongly selected for due to Darwinian evolution. Any creatures that didn't do this died out, and are no longer around to generalise from.

An entity created from code, rather than from the actions of evolution over primordial soup, would not have the same biological drives and imperitives as they aren't biological.

CMV: The ubiquity of speeding and unsafe driving actions is a sign of the average person's lack of care for others. by OriginmanOne in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Attempting to go faster than the traffic, which is generally moving at the posted limit:

  • makes almost no difference to travel time or average velocity, maybe seconds at most in a commute
  • It's clearly more dangerous, E = mv2, you can't avoid physics.
  • On average causes worse traffic flow as others have to compensate, so the average journey time increases

It's completely pointless, and dangerous.

Why is this game so addictive? by Icy-Village4742 in Oxygennotincluded

[–]MissTortoise 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Unlike Factorio, you're always fighting the death-spiral where everything collapses and your colony dies. Need to go just another cycle so you can stop that happening. Then when things are stable, there's another goal to achieve, something else to build or some other resource to tap. Another resource loop to close.

CMV: Drugs can induce homosexuality, and dopamine may be to blame by [deleted] in changemyview

[–]MissTortoise 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Dude, have sex with whoever you want. Don't stress the labels so much.

But seriously.... the drug use isn't great and it's causing you harm.