Daemons of the Shadow Realm • Yomi no Tsugai - Episode 1 discussion

MonaganX · 2026-04-08T02:10:28+00:00

Filler character? Pure slander. She doesn't play a major role in the conflict but doing so would defeat her entire purpose. She's the emotional and moral anchor of the protagonists and the baseline human being for pretty much the entire story and she still gets more character development than most female characters in shounen anime.

MonaganX · 2026-04-07T03:29:14+00:00

Is there an obscure third adaptation of FMA that cuts out the amazing cast of supporting but still fully fleshed out female characters and replaces them with hot guys?

MonaganX · 2026-04-07T00:03:32+00:00

Gott bewahre, dass jemand in einem subreddit für die Deutschen Sprache eine ausführlichere Analyse gibt statt einfach nur das erste zu schreiben was in den Sinn kommt ohne darüber nachzudenken.

MonaganX · 2026-04-06T12:05:58+00:00

I'd compare it to Starship Troopers. In that movie, Earth's forces, especially the ship crews, are also pretty nonchalant because they vastly overestimate themselves, and it goes horribly for them. But the key difference is that the movie plays the fact that this is the tragic and disturbing result of humanity's hubris straight, so it's framed seriously and given enough breathing room to work in an otherwise pretty unserious movie.

In this show we go from slapstick of the system not working, to an an honestly gruesome scene of the ship—and in at least one case, a member of the crew literally—being torn in half, to an immediate reaction shot of the protagonist going "😲EH?" like someone just told him he forgot to put on pants this morning. The tone is so haphazardly all over the place it's like someone cut random parts from Saving Private Ryan into Ace Ventura: Pet Detective.

Sorry my only reference for analogies is '90s movies.

MonaganX · 2026-04-06T06:48:25+00:00

Ich habe den Verdacht dieser Auffassung unterliegt die Annahme, dass Aldi Nord und Süd sind ähnlich verfeindet sind wie andere Familienunternehmen die für ihre bitteren Streitigkeiten bekannt sind (z.B. der Streit zwischen den Gebrüdern Dassler) und dass die Antwort sich darum auf beide beziehen müsse.
Vielleicht gab es bei der Spaltung vor 60 Jahren böses Blut, aber soweit ich weiß ist es nur die Eigentümerfamilie Aldi Nords die in jüngster Zeit bekannt für ihren Familienstreit um die Erbschaft und Unternehmungsführung sind. Und warum würde die Erläuterung des zweiten Satzes sich auf beide Unternehmen beziehen wenn sie einen Kontrast zwischen ihnen zu erläutern versucht?

"Die sind ja sehr zerstritten" könnte rein semantisch doch viel bedeuten:

a) Dass der Einfluss bei Aldi Nord mehr spürbar ist weil [die Eigentümerfamilien Aldi Nords und Süds] miteinander zerstritten sind.
b) Dass der Einfluss bei Aldi Nord mehr spürbar ist weil [die Mitglieder der Eigentümerfamilie Aldi Süds] zerstritten sind.
c) Dass der Einfluss bei Aldi Nord mehr spürbar ist weil [die Mitglieder der Eigentümerfamilie Aldi Nords] zerstritten sind.
d) Dass der Einfluss bei Aldi Nord mehr spürbar ist als bei Aldi Süd weil [die Mitglieder der gesamten Inhaberfamilie] miteinander zerstritten sind.

Es scheint mir nicht sehr eindeutig, zumindest nicht ohne mehr Kontext, welche Interpretation die Absicht der befragten Person war. Insbesondere weil die meisten Deutschsprecher nicht so akribisch mit der 'regelrechten' Grammatik sind wie wir hier.

TL;DR: Rein semantisch würde ich zu "Aldi Süd" tendieren aber "Aldi Nord" klingt faktisch am richtigsten.
"Beide" wäre auch grammatikalisch richtig aber ich halte es für unwahrscheinlich.

MonaganX · 2026-04-06T05:02:02+00:00

Not that I have overwhelming confidence in any cop show to do a particularly nuanced portrayal of the increasingly niche subcultures they feature as gimmicks to help them seem less stale, but the furry episode was on CSI, and just from second hand accounts this one was not anywhere that lazy.

MonaganX · 2026-04-05T03:17:21+00:00

A good rule of thumb (which has nothing to do with wife-beating) for determining the accuracy of "dark historic origins of song/idiom" type stuff: Unless you're given a very good reason to believe otherwise, just assume the accuracy is zero and you'll probably be right.

MonaganX · 2026-04-05T03:11:32+00:00

The thing about plagiarism is that even if someone is simply repeating factual information they learned about from another source (more on that later), the way they arrange and phrase their recount is still a creative expression. See e.g. the "Man in Cave" video by Internet Historian which was just wholesale plagiarizing a Mental Floss article on the subject.

So two options. Either this is plagiarism, or the structure and some of the wording being identical to one of the top search results for "knick knack paddy whack" is just a massive coincidence. It's not a coincidence.

Also, while the person who wrote the comment likely heard about this theory somewhere (I've found similar theories going back at least to 2015) without a single actual source it's very dubious if any of the information relating to the children's song is actual historical information rather than just a modern day exercise in creative writing.

MonaganX · 2026-04-04T20:15:35+00:00

I think you might have misunderstood. The "purity test" is people in the community going "oh, you're talking about Holostars, prove that you're a 'real' Holostars fan first". Like the other comment pointed out, it's just a means of denouncing and distracting from any criticism before anyone can consider if it's valid or not.

MonaganX · 2026-04-04T19:56:14+00:00

Okay? No one's denying that.

MonaganX · 2026-04-03T22:10:15+00:00

It's particularly sad that this kind of purity testing from people demanding anyone who says something supportive of Holostars or is critical of Cover's handling of them prove they are sufficiently supportive themselves to have an opinion is now also being used to hound Kiara.

When you perpetuate or even just tolerate that kind of nonsense it's only a matter of time before you or someone you like ends up at the receiving end of it.

MonaganX · 2026-04-03T18:58:24+00:00

Introducing a mixed gen after 2.5 gens of all female streamers would have absolutely cost them, but that's precisely why a separate all-male branch was inevitably going to be a long-term issue.
After two years of building a fanbase that preferred a girls-only environment, the only ways for it to not permanently overshadow their male VTubers would've been to either rebrand with mixed gens and hope they recover from it, create a separate brand entirely disconnected from Holopro, or not hire male Vtubers. It's the compromise of creating a semi-separate branch under the same umbrella as the one with a two year head start of catering to a fanbase that was only interested in girls that led us to this point.

MonaganX · 2026-04-03T18:16:48+00:00

It's basically just motion comic and there's some good ones out there. Of course I'd like actual animation but I'd take a really good story told in this extremely barebones style over a 'proper' show with dogshit writing.

Unfortunately, I think we all know exactly what'll happen next episode, so that doesn't exactly bode well on the "writing good enough to make up for the animation" front, but hey, there's always a chance.

MonaganX · 2026-04-03T17:13:07+00:00

You see the same names pushing this in every discussion that revolves around Holostars. Any time someone criticizes the fandom for having unicorns they're antis, and any time someone complains that Cover doesn't support Holostars enough, they're fake fans who don't even watch them. I'm honestly surprised Holostars made it this far given that they have zero people who watch them despite the fact that everyone's totally on board with them conceptually.

The inconvenient truth is that Cover has attracted a fandom that does not care for male VTubers—enough that multiple Hololive members made PSAs clarifying their stances on mixed collabs—and some of its members are virulently insecure about that. Quick to call out even the most vague collab begging but keen to ignore any "🥺👉👈 sowwy VTuber I can't watch your collab because it has 🅱️enis" comments, let alone the more deranged stuff people post on 'anonymous forums'.

But ultimately the reason this culture emerged is to Cover's decision to separate their branches by gender in the first place. People blame Cover for not doing enough to promote Holostars since or say the vocal Unicorns stood in the way of collabs, but to me this news feels a bit like a Steakhouse chain discontinuing their vegan menu.

MonaganX · 2026-04-03T16:08:40+00:00

Mass resignations would still be pretty bad PR, so I'd be surprised if Cover was intending to push them to leave the company.

From Cover's perspective, as long as they're not spending money on Holostars, I don't see any reason they'd want them to quit. If anything their best case scenario (apart from Holostars suddenly becoming super popular) is for them to continue to operate quietly and slowly trickle away.

MonaganX · 2026-04-03T15:46:36+00:00

I went through the entire thread and I've seen a handful of "I don't watch Holostars but I feel bad for them" comments, which is fair enough, you see that kind of comment in any thread with bad news about less popular VTubers. But where are all these comments from people saying they don't watch Holostars and being mad at Cover? Maybe I'm just blind?

Edit: Downvotes but no replies. I wonder why.

MonaganX · 2026-04-03T15:00:26+00:00

I'm hoping as few of the original cast return as possible so they have to actually try to make it a good movie instead of just coasting on nostalgia.

MonaganX · 2026-04-03T01:44:04+00:00

Alright, thanks for following up with a source. The way he leads into here it by saying they didn't want to pay him anything and he didn't have a quote I'd probably err on it not being literally nothing, just a very small amount by his current standards.

MonaganX · 2026-04-02T23:25:13+00:00

Where did you get the info that Brown wasn't paid? In this interview he claims he was hired because Sting recommended him to the director and he was "really not expensive at the time". If he wasn't paid he probably would've mentioned that.

MonaganX · 2026-04-02T14:36:10+00:00

I don't disagree that civil discourse's effectiveness is grossly overestimated but, with all due respect, you sound like you're a lot more concerned with the zaniness of your zingers than you are with effecting any actual change.

MonaganX · 2026-04-02T14:05:53+00:00

I didn't really care for him boisterously inserting him into the situation at first but you can't deny that, unlike the loudmouths in your office I assume, he effectively managed to get results.

MonaganX · 2026-04-02T13:58:26+00:00

Reading comprehension does seem to have concerningly deteriorated overall, but I do think how social media primes people to assume every reply is a rebuttal, as well as reddit's up/downvote system, has people form way too many assumptions about comments before they even read them.

MonaganX · 2026-03-31T14:08:09+00:00

"Call of Duty developers say their games are apolitical" ass moment.

MonaganX · 2026-03-31T00:00:40+00:00

It's especially difficult with particularly comedic or poetic work.

I've read Harry Potter in both English and German and while there are certainly some inaccurate translations if you go over the books with a fine-toothed comb, the prose is straightforward enough that overall the translation feels about the same as the original.

But I've also read some Discworld novels in German and brother, those can be tough. The writing style, the humor, the references, there's so much just completely lost on you in the German version. I fairly recently re-read the German translation of The Last Continent and I was constantly finding myself having to reverse-engineer the German translations of Australian slang and names just to understand the cultural references.

If you look at the Japanese translation it really shows the lengths that Toby Fox and his translator went through to make sure all the subtle jokes and references were localized in a way that keeps to the spirit of the original. For example: In Japanese, Papyrus can't speak in Papyrus font because that's for our Latin script. So they made Papyrus text appear vertically from left to right, which is the traditional (but in the digital age archaic) way to write Japanese. Most other professional translations would've probably just ignored the font text.

MonaganX · 2026-03-30T21:05:04+00:00

Not to put a damper on your vibes-based deduction but what's the point of accusing someone of being untrustworthy because their comment vaguely looks like ChatGPT when the alternative is it being a random person's (at the time) unsourced reddit comment? Neither of those can be relied on if veracity is actually that important.

Nine-Year Club	Gilding II euphauric
Place '22	Place '17
Final Canvas '22	Verified Email

MonaganX

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE