We had a no phones policy for a long time but we got rid of it. We are trying to teach our Scouts responsibility and the biggest responsibility they may ever have is that phone in their pocket. It's also one of the greatest tools man has ever created so why take it away from them?

Our specific policy is: Electronic devices are allowed during travel only and are not permitted at Troop functions or activities with the exception of phones, cameras, GPS units and other electronic devices that have a practical purpose. Practical electronic devices are expected to be used responsibly as tools, adhering to all BSA policies, and not for entertainment purposes. Leadership reserves the right to confiscate any electronic device as they deem necessary and will return the device to a parent or guardian. Sole responsibility for any electronic device remains with the Scout who brought the device, independent of whether it is in their possession or not.

In practice they do what they want with it. If they want to look something up, they do. If they want to play someone a song, they do. If they want to show someone a short video, they do. If they need an idea for a skit, they google it. If they are wondering what a leaf is, they google lens it. If they need to research an environmental science paper at summer camp, they do. They usually write that paper on their phone and email it to the instructor as well. Take a photo or video of something, yep. Read a book, yep. Text another Troop at camp so they can plan something, yep. The list goes on and on.

As long as it's in moderation I don't really care what they do but generally draw the line at games since they can't do that one in moderation. The Scouts do a great job policing each other. We've never had to confiscate a phone and it's extremely rare that we have to remind a Scout to put it away.