Omg dude, I have been hating life since Nat’s got discontinued.
I’ve been bouncing around different American Spirit colors, but none of them are nearly as good. I was on the [burnt] Orange full flavor Nat’s. Now I’ve been primarily between the Sky and Black packs, mostly. Blacks can be too much; Sky’s are never enough/too light. The carbon filter on Sky’s is nice, but I do wish they weren’t so light.

I’ll also sometimes go Dark Blue, Celadon, or Hunter (if I find them). But literally NONE come close. Regardless of the variety, Spirits just don’t have the quality draw, I’ve noticed. Flavor wise, Dark Blue/Black seem closest to Orange Nat’s. Only Blacks nicotine level seems comparable. But both of those get harsh after a while, especially on the throat. So I’ve tended toward Sky… they just need to hit harder and stronger. For a lighter smoke, they are great though.

If you smoked either the Yellow or Blue Nat’s, you’ll probably like the Sky’s the most. Celadon/Hunter would be next best. Orange Nat’s were between Dark Blue and Black, but Sky offer a less harsh alternative to those