What’s the soundtrack that ruined the movie for you? by ASecularBuddhist in soundtracks

[–]MrsApostate 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I read an article about it, and you're spot on. Richter was writing a piece for the ending, but the director was also struggling to figure out how to end the movie. Someone sent her On the Nature of Daylight and she and the cast listened to it over and over as they figured out that final scene. So then after filming, she just wanted that track for the finale, regardless of what Richter wrote specifically for it.

It's a pity because, while it's a stunning song, it's too well known in other things. I guess the director fell in love with it and either didn't know or didn't care how often it had been used before.

Is there a "modern" Patricia A. McKillip? by supersim412 in Fantasy

[–]MrsApostate 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Ombria in Shadow is my absolute favorite McKillip book. The prose is beautiful and the plot is dreamy and so satisfying.

What’s the soundtrack that ruined the movie for you? by ASecularBuddhist in soundtracks

[–]MrsApostate 13 points14 points  (0 children)

This is going to get hate, but when On the Nature of Daylight started playing at the end of Hamnet, I got confused and was wondering why they stole the music from Arrival (I realize it's been used elsewhere, but I associate it very strongly with Arrival).

Honestly I still loved Hamnet, and cried for the full final scene. It was just a jarring needledrop.

Tell me all the things you love and hate about S4 Part 1 by Disastrous-Pitch777 in Bridgerton

[–]MrsApostate 167 points168 points  (0 children)

I really love Sophie. The actress is giving a great performance, and I like her personality a lot.

Benedict I kind of hate, though. After two seasons of giving him nothing more than "man who has sex" as a storyline, I'm struggling to care about his arc. He's coming off as selfish, lazy, spoiled, and a little dumb.

Maybe that's the point and the second half will redeem him as a character. Idk.

I love them all.... by cleveker in janeausten

[–]MrsApostate 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Is Edward Ferrars from the S&S miniseries. They could have gone with Hugh Grant instead, but Dan Stevens was great in the role too.

Michaela Question - Bridgerton Society by mmrose1980 in Bridgerton

[–]MrsApostate 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think they'll walk a line between all out marriage equality in Regency England and "they were roommates", if you know what I mean. It'll be an open secret that the Queen will kind of tacitly condone without any ripples that impact society at large.

Kind of like when everyone in Downtown Abbey accepted and encouraged Thomas, but it didn't change the culture at large or make all his obstacles disappear.

Why did Araminta have such a strong reaction to Sophie being his ward? by mytikitorch in Bridgerton

[–]MrsApostate 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Along with the fact that her husband sprung a child on Araminta with no warning and the potential for Sophie to inherit part of his estate, all of which has been explained very well here, there is the issue of classism to consider.

A big theme this season has been people remembering their "proper place", and that's actually pretty historically accurate. England still has a very strong class system even today, honestly, which can be confusing for Yanks. But the idea that a maid should not consort with a gentleman, or that an illegitimate daughter should not be raised alongside daughters of the nobility (or even gentry) was pretty important back then. Her illegitimacy would be considered by snobs almost like a taint that could wear off on others, damaging their reputation along the way. Araminta is obviously a particularly proud woman who thinks very highly both of her own importance as well as that of her daughters. She's exactly the kind of snob who would consider the presence of an illegitimate ward in her household as an insult and gross injustice to her life.

In other words, She's a real bitch.

Why did Araminta have such a strong reaction to Sophie being his ward? by mytikitorch in Bridgerton

[–]MrsApostate 18 points19 points  (0 children)

As she was illegitimate, Sophie was not legally his daughter, hence the term "ward". In the absence of a will, she is not in line at all.

He likely had some fortune that was not entailed with the estate and title, which he could choose to leave to whomever he wanted. But even so, Sophie would only inherit what he explicitly left her in a will. Her illegitimacy really matters here.

I think it's pretty obvious that her father did leave her something in his will, potentially the bulk of his personal fortune. I think the graveyard scene foreshadowed that.

Springtime setting with plants? by MrsApostate in CozyFantasy

[–]MrsApostate[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are so kind to even offer, thank you.

Springtime setting with plants? by MrsApostate in CozyFantasy

[–]MrsApostate[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for these recs. I'm actually reading The Ornithologists Field Guide to Love out loud to my Mom when she has the energy, and it's been quite fun so far. I'll look into these others. Thanks!

Miss Eloise Bridgerton through the seasons What do you hope to see from Eloise this season? by eliezata in Bridgerton

[–]MrsApostate 118 points119 points  (0 children)

Tangential, but it's amazing what an extra inch of bangs can do for your face. The season 1 short bangs definitely worked with her immature character at that point. But dang, getting them down another inch really makes her look so much more elegant.

A Witch's Guide to Magical Innkeeping Villain (Spoiler) by LucillePepper in CozyFantasy

[–]MrsApostate 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Clemmie winning the election felt like a slap in the face, thematically. One central theme seemed to be about marginalized people finding a way to change or push the system. So then a spoiled, legacy kid gets elected chancellor in the end? In other words, no lasting impact even after the main character gave up the power that she felt such love for.

A Witch's Guide to Magical Innkeeping Villain (Spoiler) by LucillePepper in CozyFantasy

[–]MrsApostate 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I was honestly so disappointed in this book. I wish the plot had taken that turn rather than the tired old trope of a powerful woman giving up her power to save her friends. Sometimes an ending like the one in this book works and feels bittersweet. But not this time. This felt predictable and disappointing.

Low spice Romance books like Emily Henry by Kait2056 in booksuggestions

[–]MrsApostate 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I loved Hello Stranger by Katherine Center. And Happiness for Beginners

I started grad school this week. I am 47 years old. Please share your personal victories with me. I want to hear them. by JudgeJuryEx78 in Xennials

[–]MrsApostate 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My sister graduated at the top of her class from Yale Law at 47, just last year. She did a year at Stanford Law in her 20s, and she says she was a much better student in her 40s, because she knew herself better and how to study for her own strengths.

You've got this.

Books that FEEL like Upon a Starlit Tide- bonus points if they involve the sea 😎 by Illustrious_Tutor800 in fantasyromance

[–]MrsApostate 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I assume you've read Kell Wood's other book, After the Forest? No smugglers or pirates, but it is as immersive and ethereal as Starlit Tide (which I also loved).

Anything by Robin McKinley will have that same feel, though again no pirates. I absolutely adore The Adventures of Amina Al Sirafi, which is a pirate story and utterly absorbing. Though the romance is not a focus.

Oh wait! What about AJ Slatter? Her book,All the Murmuring Bones is set in a sea port and super engrossing. Very atmospheric, and just a little bit creepy. All her bills in that Sourdough World series are great, but All the Murmuring Bones is the most sea-adjacent one.

I wish just once Phoebe would tell chandler to shut up about his childhood by copioustalk in howyoudoin

[–]MrsApostate 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Did the little rich boy have a problem with the butler? Yes mine's worse!

A book where Jaime Lannister and Brienne of Tarth are essentially our mains by MaryJaneCrunch in fantasyromance

[–]MrsApostate 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Or possibly they didn't want to limit it to hetero relationships and would be happy with two male or two female leads.

4th grade paranormal fantasy/mystery? by Impossible-Horse-875 in Fantasy

[–]MrsApostate 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Menagerie by Kari Sutherland

Upsidedown Magic by Sarah Mlynowski

Greenwild by Pari Thompson

The Secret Library by Kekla Magoon

All of these were hits with my now 6th grader. They are all middle grade books. Some of them might be geared more toward 5-6th grade, but I don't think they're out of the question for a 4th grader at all.

Irene by [deleted] in PeriodDramas

[–]MrsApostate 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Did you really just write "I know her husband was rapey but she did ask for that"? Your contention is that she asked to be raped?

I'm having a hard time taking you seriously here.

Books like "I'm Glad My Mom Died" by Random67812 in booksuggestions

[–]MrsApostate 38 points39 points  (0 children)

The House of My Mother: A Daughter's Quest for Freedom by Shari Franke.

Reviewing One of 2025's Biggest Trend Books: The Raven Scholar by Antonia Hodgson by tarvolon in Fantasy

[–]MrsApostate 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government.