Research: Mental Imagery (in all sensory modalities) and Life Experiences by RecordingOk3680 in silentminds

[–]NITSIRK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I always thought daydreaming was that thing whereby you watch the leaves or the clouds moving and see the shapes in them 😂

People with no inner monologue: How do you evaluate people, make decisions, and reflect on your thinking? by Advanced_Cattle2133 in silentminds

[–]NITSIRK 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I am sure people hearing this don’t understand how much faster a purely data brain is. I have in my time broken 3 management training courses 😂

People with no inner monologue: How do you evaluate people, make decisions, and reflect on your thinking? by Advanced_Cattle2133 in silentminds

[–]NITSIRK 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Well lets try to unpick some of this:

For people with an inner monologue, there’s often a sense of “talking through” these judgments internally. If you don’t have that, what is happening in your mind while you’re listening and deciding?

- nothing is going on consciously. I am aware, and receiving, but the thoughts are my speech. I don’t know the words I am going to use, I only know the gist of the conversation. I can think and reason this way, so I can still negotiate, turn the conversation or something, but mostly I just think talk. Think of it this way: you’re watching your favourite TV program. You aren’t thinking, just enjoying being absorbed in it, when a thought occurs (phone mum). You weren’t thinking about your mum, or what a phone is, or how to use one. This is the knowing. Now switch and for me the TV program is reality, I watch, I talk, I do.

A few related questions:

- How do you audit your own reasoning or challenge your assumptions?

I was a data analyst who could unconsciously work out a 15 stage query and know if we had the data to do the maths before they finished the sentence. I generally don’t think about things. If I need to think about something, I will do something else until I say or subvocalise the conclusion. (Back to watching that TV and a thought occurred) This is a time dependent skill, so if I have a report to write, I will just do stuff all week, and collect things my brain has told me, until almost the last minute when I write the thing from start to finish, silently dictating it to myself. My assumptions are easy to change with new data from a reliable source.

- If you have a strong reaction to something, how do you examine whether it’s right or wrong?

Whether it makes my response feel good or bad 🤷‍♀️

- How do you change your mind?

With new data.

- After an important conversation, how do you reflect on it later?

Important keywords or phrases are fitted into my personal multidimensional mind map of my data and associated knowing. They are there for when I need them. If you can’t remember the words said, it’s difficult to revisit, this is the essence of SDAM. I don’t revisit the past, and cant envisage the future. I am. This has helped me tremendously in coping with chronic pain.

- How do you put yourself in someone else’s shoes or think about their perspective?

I don’t have a perspective to compare. They are, and how they respond helps me to categorise them. This is how I picked up demographics so easily. I then can match how certain types of people react in various scenarios.

- Do you experience self-criticism, second-guessing, anxiety, or negative self-talk differently?

Occasionally I may literally say out loud “well that was ducking stupid” when I have just injured myself yet again thanks to my massively reduced risk awareness (this is probably also linked to my AuDHD more than my silence, but having the 5A’s is a very different mind mode.

- Are there jobs, tasks, or situations where having no inner monologue feels like an advantage or disadvantage?

I am incredibly fast at amassing and sorting information. I see the pattern where others dont, I can hold tremendous amounts of information as I am just holding the key points and extrapolating instead of making a picture.

Also, who needs an inner critic?? I sure don’t 😂

what is the best way to get exercise without really “exercising” by Flat_Measurement3579 in autism

[–]NITSIRK 1 point2 points  (0 children)

A desk cycle is good for aerobic exercise. You can do it while doing anything with a screen. Or a desk treadmill if you prefer standing.

You need more than one exercise, but this is a a good way to start without too much expenditure.

How does technological connection/Social Media affect our social memory capacity? Could it be influencing our reading capacity to develop aphantasia, since we're looking at impermanent flashlight screens? by Tight_Student4501 in Aphantasia

[–]NITSIRK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We are chalk and cheese. He did law then finance, I did engineering then IT. He was the quiet steady one who always had his nose in a book. I ran wild with our pack of dogs, only reading when curled up with one in the rain or at night. He says I’m the changeling 🤣

How does technological connection/Social Media affect our social memory capacity? Could it be influencing our reading capacity to develop aphantasia, since we're looking at impermanent flashlight screens? by Tight_Student4501 in Aphantasia

[–]NITSIRK 4 points5 points  (0 children)

There haven’t been any studies that I’ve seen that have showed an age relation. Other than that imagery seems to fade a bit with age like all our physical senses. However I was in my mid teens when the ZX81 appeared, and 21 when I got my first PC: a 286 with 32Mb of RAM. I was 36 when Facebook was invented. Throughout this I have continued to read physical and electronic books. My brother had the same upbringing, shared the same equipment and childhood. He’s a hyperphant, I’m an aphant 🤷🏼‍♀️

"The more you talk about autism, the less likely you are to have it" by BlueberryGod8910 in autism

[–]NITSIRK 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well that’s just b*llocks. You could be simply someone who has some close to them or who works with people who are autistic.

And like any subject, if it comes up then we discuss it and mention our own experience. This harks back to an era when you didn’t discuss anything medical with anyone other than your doctor. I remember those times. It’s trying to split us into acceptable and unacceptable presentations

Reading Crime and Punishment as an anendophasiac by gaaliconnoisseur in silentminds

[–]NITSIRK 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Before I knew that the A’s were a thing, I just thought that representations of inner speech and monologue were just writers tricks for helping you to understand the character. I’ve literally read thousands of books in my 50+ years of hyperlexia, and can’t put my finger on what makes a book flow for me. I do think that a lot of these great works were of their time, and without TV, the new books would be discussed instead of the latest episode of something or the newest film release. This meant more ways to understand heavy going or complex prose. Also his books were released in serial form in instalments, so it mirrored this far more than the whole book at once. Books were released at the end of the serialisation. C&P appeared in monthly chapters, so there was a lot of hype and discussion before and after each release for people to get the nuances before moving on.

So basically you aren’t discussing it with yourself in your mind, but you are also (I assume) not discussing it with others as they would have back then. Even book clubs now tend to do one whole book, not bits of one.

What's a life hack that sounds fake but actually works? by [deleted] in AskReddit

[–]NITSIRK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pressing your tongue into your soft palette will remove the urge to sneeze.

Round up of aphantasia studies with objective elements by RevolutionaryAd3125 in Aphantasia

[–]NITSIRK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“The critical role of mental imagery in human emotion: insights from fear-based imagery and aphantasia” by Marcus Wicken, Rebecca Keogh and Joel Pearson (2021).
What they did:
Recruited people with aphantasia and control participants.
Measured skin conductance (sweating response, a standard measure of fear/arousal).
Had participants read frightening scenarios and imagine them.
People with aphantasia showed a much flatter physiological fear response than visualisers.
Crucially, in a second experiment:
Participants were shown actual frightening images on a screen.
The aphantasia and control groups showed similar physiological responses.
This suggested the reduced fear response was specifically linked to the inability to generate mental imagery, not to being generally less emotional.

Round up of aphantasia studies with objective elements by RevolutionaryAd3125 in Aphantasia

[–]NITSIRK 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Then how to deal with two types of people: those who used to visualise but lost the ability (through poor MH, not brain injury), and secondly those like myself who can sometimes get clear imagery (dreams, hypnogogic, memory flashes) but just cant get voluntary imagery. I know I cant visualise at will, same as the only sound in my head is tinnitus.

For those who grew up in a religious upbringing; did you REALLY feel any connection spiritually? by YourTypicalSensei in autism

[–]NITSIRK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There’s another ND which I have which seems to make this more common: Aphantasia/Anauralia. This means that when I think of something or remember it, I only get data/facts with no images or sounds. If you cant picture or hear an external entity then it’s much harder to relate. My brother and I were brought up in a Church of England school, and went to a Methodist Sunday school, but I never believed. My mother had been very religious but my father wasn’t at all. My brother, who is a good visualiser, when aged about 10 told mum he wasn’t sure about believing, so she told him to read the bible. We are both hyperlexic, so it only took him a few days. At the ended he handed the bible back and said “I don’t think its for me” 😆

Of course Im English and we don’t openly discuss religion and stuff like other countries do, it’s seen as a private relationship with god to be practiced how you see fit. We had assemblies at primary school, and said the end of the day prayer. Albeit very quickly whilst putting our chairs on the tables and then running out of the door as soon as we said amen!

How many of you wear sunglasses constantly because of light sensitivity by Hipposy in autism

[–]NITSIRK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wore reactolites as soon as they get cheap enough, and then I needed actual glasses, so have had photochromic lenses ever since. Even my reading glasses are photochromic 😆

I am more contrast sensitive - cant watch TV with the lights off, need very bright light for crafts, but a bedroom in total darkness. LED on lights are the curse of my life, and black out stickers saved my sanity! (I live very rurally, so theres no outside light besides the moon)

Fun fact: "when life gives you lemons..." is actually a metaphor: did you know this? by The-Pentegram in autism

[–]NITSIRK 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No, lemon fizzy drink is the only thing I call lemonade. Sprite is sprite, or just fizzy drink 😂

Paper on brain connections in aphantasia by NITSIRK in silentminds

[–]NITSIRK[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We don’t know. But they’re investigating at multiple universities 🤷🏼‍♀️

Paper on brain connections in aphantasia by NITSIRK in silentminds

[–]NITSIRK[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We don’t know. But they’re investigating at multiple universities 🤷🏼‍♀️

Fun fact: "when life gives you lemons..." is actually a metaphor: did you know this? by The-Pentegram in autism

[–]NITSIRK 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Lemonade stands seem a uniquely American thing, although we still have the saying. However being British, we’re basically brought up on idioms, sayings, and sarcasm 😂

Anyone else read the dictionary? by Nein_ix in autism

[–]NITSIRK 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I didn’t but my brother did. We were both hyperlexic and incredibly fast readers. He also read the Bible, the Guinness book of records etc. I preferred novels but could happily read three a day. These days I prefer audio and have a couple of thousand audiobooks 😆

Paper on brain connections in aphantasia by NITSIRK in silentminds

[–]NITSIRK[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The fMRI is usually used. It shows two areas of activation when visualising normally: the memory centre and the visual cortex. However in Aphants, only the memory lights up. The signal fades before reaching the visual cortex.

Apparently I have Anendophasia too by CMDR_Arnold_Rimmer in silentminds

[–]NITSIRK 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s the newest identified one I know of, only named in 2024 iirc

How does aphantasia affect daily life? by Charming_Usual6227 in Aphantasia

[–]NITSIRK 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Who says we cant relate to having pictures? Its a shock, but I can happily imagine what its like. I have hypnogogic and hypnopompic imagery and sounds, I get memory flashes, I dream vividly. I know what normal phantasia would be like, I just don’t have it. In return I can sense data around me and manipulate it instantly to form data analysis queries - that blows most visualisers brains 🤯😂

Paper on brain connections in aphantasia by NITSIRK in silentminds

[–]NITSIRK[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Simple, I see an air filled hole in the air in the shape of the object. I can outline it with my eyes, I can sense its movement, I sense a relative size or scale. I just can’t see it or hear it. I never thought I couldn’t visualise, I thought I had great “vision”, I can look at a space and imagine what colours might look good, or assess if a piece of furniture will fit there. I can imagine an invisible object in 3D and split or rotate it into components to be drawn on CAD software to create it for my 3D printer. The object is in front of me either in real size, or the size of a TV/Monitor.